Microsoft finds a new way to irritate Windows 11 users – a backup pop-up
- Reference: 1722268927
- News link: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2024/07/29/microsoft_onedrive_popup/
- Source link:
First spotted by [1]WindowsLatest , the pop-up looks like something a user might see during the setup of Windows 11. However, in this instance, it appears when Windows 11 starts up and describes the benefits of backing up a PC with OneDrive.
According to the pop-up, there's a lifetime of memories to be stashed away (assuming they'll fit into the woefully inadequate 5 GB of storage the OneDrive service has by default), options for collaboration, and, most usefully, the option to synchronize storage to the cloud with changes being automatically updated.
[2]
A user having their information in the cloud is undoubtedly helpful when hopping from device to device, although it also carries risks. OneDrive is, after all, just one of Microsoft's cloud tentacles and not immune to outages when another service suffers disruption. And then there is the inherent risk of unwanted data changes rippling through devices.
[3]
[4]
Finally, even if a user does buy into Microsoft's vision for cloudy storage, there might not be an official client for all of your devices. Mac users are catered for, but Linux users are not, not by Microsoft, at any rate.
[5]How a cheap barcode scanner helped fix CrowdStrike'd Windows PCs in a flash
[6]Windows Patch Tuesday update might send a user to the BitLocker recovery screen
[7]How did a CrowdStrike file crash millions of Windows computers? We take a closer look at the code
[8]EU gave CrowdStrike the keys to the Windows kernel, claims Microsoft
The suggestion can be skipped but will more than likely make its presence felt again in the future.
Should a user accept Microsoft's offer, OneDrive will start synchronizing their PC, right up until that 5 GB default storage is exhausted. After that, the company will happily offer users more capacity in its cloud for a fee.
Backing up files has always been a good idea, although shoveling data into the cloud is not always the best way to recover from a disaster. There is also an inherent risk in file synchronization services – ask those unfortunate users who found months' worth of data suddenly [9]go missing from Google Drive .
[10]
However, imposing a full-screen pop-up on Windows 11 users that urges them to back up their files using another Microsoft product is perhaps an upsell too far, particularly considering how much of the Windows experience [11]is devoted to ads nowadays. ®
Get our [12]Tech Resources
[1] https://www.windowslatest.com/2024/07/28/windows-11-now-shows-a-full-screen-pop-up-to-use-onedrive-and-protect-your-pc/
[2] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_software/oses&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=2&c=2ZqgRB5U7C0V72M0l2qCYDgAAAME&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D2%26raptor%3Dcondor%26pos%3Dtop%26test%3D0
[3] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_software/oses&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=4&c=44ZqgRB5U7C0V72M0l2qCYDgAAAME&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D4%26raptor%3Dfalcon%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0
[4] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_software/oses&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=3&c=33ZqgRB5U7C0V72M0l2qCYDgAAAME&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D3%26raptor%3Deagle%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0
[5] https://www.theregister.com/2024/07/25/crowdstrike_remediation_with_barcode_scanner/
[6] https://www.theregister.com/2024/07/24/windows_update_bitlocker/
[7] https://www.theregister.com/2024/07/23/crowdstrike_failure_shows_need_for/
[8] https://www.theregister.com/2024/07/22/windows_crowdstrike_kernel_eu/
[9] https://www.theregister.com/2023/11/27/google_drive_files_disappearing/
[10] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_software/oses&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=4&c=44ZqgRB5U7C0V72M0l2qCYDgAAAME&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D4%26raptor%3Dfalcon%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0
[11] https://www.theregister.com/2024/04/24/adverts_windows_11/
[12] https://whitepapers.theregister.com/
Re: When will users decide that enough is enough?
Didn't you know clicky-clicky is the main ingredient of the "user experience" ;) They love it!
Re: When will users decide that enough is enough?
> And give MS the finger?
Yea... great. But what are the options?
If only there were more versions of Linux from which to choose...
Re: But what are the options?
An optical drive with a DVD-RW.
Of course, that means you need to work a bit.
It also means that, once that DVD is closed, you have upwards of 20 years of data security. All you need to do is remember where that DVD is.
Just say NO!
Microsoft are just on one long seemingly endless drive to grab customers' data and make them cash slaves to Redmond.
Re: Just say NO!
Seemingly?
Understatement of the century.
Give us all your data! Pretty Please
Pinky Promise not to mine it and train AI on it!
Oh and you'll need to give us some money too. Data Mining^W errr, Storage, doesn't come cheap!
As posted 4 months ago, verbatim.
Dear Microsoft.
Fuck off
Fuck off and keep fucking off until you reach escape velocity.
Don't stop fucking off for a single moment. Keep fucking off past Mars, the gas giants, then Neptune, Uranus and Pluto.
Stay with the fucking off theme as you leave, first the solar system, then the galactic arm
Fuck off right out of the whole galaxy, then the local cluster.
Keep on going, on and on until you reach the edge of the universe.
Then fuck off right out of our universe and take your tawdry, ad infested start menu with you.
AND DON'T COME BACK
Capiche?
Yours, with an almost indescribable amount of molten lava prejudice, laced with the contents of my septic tank.
Another Advert
While it is a good idea to back-up files, this is just another plug (or advert if you prefer) for OneDrive. Microsoft don't give a shit about people backing up their files. Is there no end to their cash grab?
Re: Another Advert
No
Re: Another Advert
Correct answer!
Re: Microsoft don't give a shit about people backing up their files.
Anyone here old enough to have used MS DOS may remember the BACKUP and RESTORE utilities provided by MS.
These were fine for backing up files within the same MS DOS version, but woe betide migrating to a different version of MS DOS (even point number increases of version). The utilities were not backward compatible, but they had the same filenames. So if you wanted to move to a new pc with a new OS, take a deep breath. You had to use the new BACKUP/RESTORE on your old computer (or vice versa, assuming the old pc was still bootable).
Not so fast though... when you tried to do that it said you can't do this as it was the incorrect version. You had to fiddle around with a utility called SETVER.
TL;DR This is not a new revelation.
Ooh, let me guess…
…clicking the X in the corner of the popup (assuming there is one), or pressing Alt-F4, is interpreted as “yes, PLEASE sign me up for this and start slurping my data”?
Can’t let dogmatic adherence to decades-old UI conventions get in the way when there’s cross-brand marketing synergy to be actualized.
Ugh. I just threw up in my mouth a little typing that last sentence.
Re: Ooh, let me guess…
And even then...when the next Windows update drops Microsoft will just re-enable the backup all my files to OneDrive option.
Backup Priorities
...OneDrive will start synchronizing their PC, right up until that 5 GB default storage is exhausted.
And it will helpfully prioritize the important files and directories to backup, starting with cache directories, temp directories and Microsoft's OS files. The backup will not be able to save any of your data because you ran out of space...
Re: Backup Priorities
Didn’t forget the recovery option, the download bandwidth will be throttled so as to encourage people to subscribe to the restore service, which involves MS copying;g your backup to multiple USB devices and mail8ng them to you.
Dear Register: Just stop!
You're making want to not upgrade ...
Re: Dear Register: Just stop!
Congratulations. You're waking up.
Don't worry, you can still take the blue pill.
Seems mighty insecure
I don't use OneDrive at all, though I am happy enough to use Windows 10 Pro (carefully) as my user environment. Why would I want Microsoft to have copies of my files, especially confidential work and personal materials? Do you trust them as safekeepers of your private data? For a kid who just plays games and wants to save scores, sure. But for serious work? I don't want to be the product.
The thing is…
Even when you dismiss this festering piece of crap from your screen, it will still be there …taking up disk space and (probably) memory too. Probably a couple of hundred MB at least (a “hello world” program seems to take close that these days - that’s the shitty state of software out there, but I digress). It will sit there lurking. Waiting to be awoken again. It’s probably even consuming clock cycles too with a “check if it should be displayed again” timer. Like a sleeper agent in some post war spy thriller.
Anyway, sleep well
Re: The thing is…
> Probably a couple of hundred MB at least (a “hello world” program seems to take close that these days - ...)
Not so long ago, I tried my hand at coding using the WinUI3 framework, which - supposedly - is Microsoft's recommended framework for Windows 10 & 11 apps (you know - Acrylic Blur, pages, all that good stuff).
Well, apart from the fact that at the time, only 8 months or so ago, there was no sodding visual editor for WinUI3 in Visual Studio , and the recommendation from MS was to build-view-tweak-build-review-tweak-etc until satisfied (!), I do recall that a simple "Hello World" program in a dialog-type window compiled out to something ridiculous like 150MB, and the build process vomited a thousand discrete files into the output directory, all of which were apparently a) vital to the execution of the program, and b) not simply duplicates of existing Windows system library files.
So anyway, I went back to WPF & Winforms. Call me a dinosaur if you wish.
ondrive mac
For a long time if you installed ondrive on a mac you could find yourself spending days or weeks trying to figure out why onedrive was failing on a mac. turns out that the macs idea of a valid filenames and onedrives idea of a valid filename weren't the same. Pretty much all the other companies that did backups didn't have these problems, just microsoft. Besides, by default ondrive doesn't do backups, it does an archive by moving data from the computer to the cloud, at least the business defaults done here.
Re: ondrive mac
It's not just OneDrive for Mac. It is perfectly possible to have a file stored on a Windows machine and accessed by OneDrive for Windows which has a filename which causes OneDrive for Windows to have palpitations. Guess how I _know_ this for certain.
Best of all, if the organization providing the OneDrive (a prominent local 3try level educational institution, for example) were to have an agreement with MS about certain things ('free' copies of MS Office, with 1 glorious TB of OneDrive storage built-in), then should someone (oh, me, for example) contact MS Support on this matter they don't want to know. I was referred back to school IT support. Exactly what the school's IT people were supposed to do is unclear. I changed the name and the problem went away. Note that all, repeat ALL of the machines involved were running MS software: the desktop assigned to the instructor's podium, Win10 Enterprise; the laptop handed out by the school, Win10Education ; my personal laptop, Win10Pro; the servers the school uses, assorted WinServer 2019/2022 systems, all running ActiveDirectory; whatever the hell MS uses for OneDrive at their end. Note also that DropBox had no problems with the same file using the original name. And putting that file on a Mac also failed to cause problems. Why, it's almost as though MS's left hand doesn't know which bloody county the right hand is in, much less what the right hand is doing.
Re: Win10Education
"What did you learn about at school today, dear?"
"Oh, we learned that Windows is a steaming pile of..."
(I'm sure Joyce Grenfell would intervene at this juncture).
"...Microsoft finds a new way to irritate..."
As if we can't remember Steve Sinofski........you know......Windows 8.
Or Julie Larson-Green....you know....."the ribbon".
Windows 98 did it for me.............since then twenty five years with Linux has been......peachy...................
It's not full-screen, but it is large; the same size as the one that keeps popping up for MS Store whether you ask for it or not. This one can be made to away though, by disabling One Drive. As has been noted, it could come back next patch Tuesday though. Sigh.
a backup pop-up
Often the way I first hear about these things is when one of my customers tries to remote-in to their pc in the office and find that it has been taken over by some mystical entity. Usually the solution is for me to dial-in and see for myself, then explain what to do the next time it arises.
Note to Microsoft:- Not everyone in this world has hours to kill pondering the Shiny New Things you inflict upon us. I know it has been said before, but if MS manufactured cars you would have to have someone on call to do things like "clear the windscreen" or rearrange the seats before you can get in to drive to work. It would be great for people using public transport on the day after Patch Tuesday though... not a car on the road for the first half of the morning. Hmmm, hey Microsoft, why don't you go into the car manufacturing business?
Re: a backup pop-up
>if MS manufactured cars you would have to have someone on call to do things like "clear the windscreen" ...
You'd be driving along at 60mph, making good time, feeling good about life, when suddenly the entire windscreen would be taken over by a giant advert for Microsoft OneGear, or Radio 365, or an exhortation to use your Microsoft account to unlock & start the car rather than that primitive car-key in your pocket.
I'll stop there because it's like shooting fish in a barrel.
When will users decide that enough is enough?
And give MS the finger?
At the moment, it seems that everything that they do is guaranteed to piss off users... big time.
Come on people, vote with your feet and give them the old heave ho.
You know that you want to... The time is now isn't it?
Proudly windows free since Sept 30, 2016.