News: 1697717813

  ARM Give a man a fire and he's warm for a day, but set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life (Terry Pratchett, Jingo)

First Brexit, now X-it: Musk 'considering' pulling platform from EU over probe

(2023/10/19)


Comment Elon Musk is said to be toying with the idea of withdrawing access to X in the European Union rather than go to the effort of complying with the bloc's Digital Services Act.

As The Register [1]reported last week, His Muskiness had a rather public spat on the website with Thierry Breton, EU Commissioner for Internal Market, who was simply reminding social media platforms of their content moderation obligations under the law.

This was particularly in light of renewed hostilities between Israel and Hamas, and the potential disinformation campaigns that had begun swirling online. Meta, TikTok, and YouTube were also sent letters.

[2]

"Free speech absolutist" Musk's response was [3]sarcastic and juvenile , the kind of smack talk that would get a teen grounded. It would take a couple of days for the adult in the room, CEO Linda Yaccarino, to get a [4]formal response written.

[5]

[6]

However, by then the EU had indicated that X was now [7]under investigation on account of its designation as Very Large Online Platform under the Digital Services Act, which means it has to follow rules regarding how it handles illegal content [8]among many other things .

The website was given a deadline of October 18 (yesterday) to provide information on the "activation and functioning of X's crisis response protocol" and October 31 for other requested details.

[9]

Seeing how X has been gutted to become a husk of what it once was (Twitter), we imagine its crisis response protocol to be staffers running around what operational offices it has left screaming.

Since Musk increasingly appears to see [10]obeying the law as optional for him, it would be very unlike the X owner to actually do anything, and whispers out of the company seem to support this.

That most watertight of sources, "a person familiar with the matter," told [11]Insider that Musk "has discussed simply removing the app's availability in the region, or blocking users in the European Union from accessing it," much like how Meta's Threads [12]declined to launch in the EU because it was unwilling and/or unable to meet the union's onerous data protection and privacy requirements.

[13]

The reason why it could be easier to pull the plug than bend to European bureaucracy is because X's moderation teams have been almost entirely dismantled. The platform's Trust and Safety Council, a group of volunteers Twitter once consulted on matters of online harms, was [14]outright deleted .

As a result, Twitter, which was once intensely moderated, has become a wild west of violence, misinformation, disinformation, racism, and hardcore pornography. Many of the website's rules judging what users can and can't post have been screwed up and tossed in the trash.

[15]X marks the bot: Musk thinks spammers won't pay $1 a year

[16]Australia threatens X with fine, warns Google, for failure to comply with child abuse handling report regs

[17]EU threatens X with DSA penalties over spread of Israel-Hamas disinformation

[18]Musk in hot water with SEC for failure to comply with subpoena

Zooming out, an estimated 6,000 people have been let go since Musk acquired Twitter for $44 billion last year and began its pivot to the "everything app" X. That's 80 percent of the former workforce, meaning the platform may simply not have enough boots on the ground to implement what governments require.

The sources claimed Musk "immediately" wanted to limit Twitter's operations to the US, and that has more or less borne out thanks to the company deciding to stop paying office rent in multiple locations.

"That's part of the reason he gutted international teams the first chance he got," they said. According to Insider's sources, Twitter's offices in London and Dublin remain operational, but those in Paris, Madrid, and Berlin have been shut, and "essentially no employees remain in Europe."

While Musk's takeover continues to be observed as [19]one nonsensical business decision after another , withdrawing from Europe could further damage X revenue for what is an already cash-strapped company following the exodus of advertisers for reasons made clear earlier.

A Very Large Online Platform under the Digital Services Act is one that can reach 10 percent of the EU's population. Europe makes up about 9 percent of X's global monthly active user base, though figures from Apptopia say usage has dropped significantly across the region over the past three months by 10-40 percent.

Yet when money is no object – Musk's net worth is $255.9 billion – perhaps it's not important. Insider's sources said the world's richest man has met with Breton on a couple of occasions to hash out what X needs to do, but "he's lost patience with the situation."

"He's very quick to drop the hammer on anyone who he doesn't like," they said, "or who says something that he views as challenging him." This is true – look at how Musk reacted when he found out [20]Bill Gates was shorting Tesla stock .

Basically, no one can say what Musk is prepared to do, though deactivating X in Europe could be a blessing in disguise for the people living there. Brits, however, no longer beholden to EU law after Brexit, may not be so lucky.

Remote working 'detached from reality'

In other MuskWatch news, Elon, who is also Tesla CEO, [21]raged against remote work during the electric car company's Q3 earnings call, describing those who maximize shareholder value from the comfort of their own homes as "detached from reality," which is a bit rich, isn't it?

He said the people who ask "Why doesn't everyone work from home?" give off "real Marie Antoinette vibes." He went on: "How detached from reality does the work-from-home crowd have to be? While they take advantage of those who cannot work from home. Why did I sleep in the factory so many times? Because it mattered."

Musk also claims to be [22]deeply concerned about population collapse yet having a career is so often at odds with the concept of raising children. Working from home allows parents to get their kids to school and be back at their desk before 9am because they don't have to leave at 7:30 to travel across the country.

When you have an infinite money tree like Musk, you can pay other people to raise your children, clean your house, and manage whatever menial tasks you cannot because you're sleeping at the office. However, most people do not have this luxury.

Talk about detached from reality. ®

Get our [23]Tech Resources



[1] https://www.theregister.com/2023/10/11/eu_threatens_x_with_dsa/

[2] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_onprem/personaltech&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=2&c=2ZTFSqrsWhAocv@fWJFKF3gAAABQ&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D2%26raptor%3Dcondor%26pos%3Dtop%26test%3D0

[3] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1711832919335976991

[4] https://twitter.com/lindayaX/status/1712342353304846603

[5] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_onprem/personaltech&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=4&c=44ZTFSqrsWhAocv@fWJFKF3gAAABQ&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D4%26raptor%3Dfalcon%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0

[6] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_onprem/personaltech&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=3&c=33ZTFSqrsWhAocv@fWJFKF3gAAABQ&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D3%26raptor%3Deagle%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0

[7] https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_23_4953

[8] https://www.theregister.com/2023/04/26/amazon_app_store_bookingcom_and/

[9] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_onprem/personaltech&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=4&c=44ZTFSqrsWhAocv@fWJFKF3gAAABQ&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D4%26raptor%3Dfalcon%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0

[10] https://www.theregister.com/2023/10/06/musk_in_hot_water_with/

[11] https://archive.ph/jvNtQ

[12] https://www.theregister.com/2023/07/05/threads_comes_to_uk/

[13] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_onprem/personaltech&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=3&c=33ZTFSqrsWhAocv@fWJFKF3gAAABQ&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D3%26raptor%3Deagle%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0

[14] https://www.theregister.com/2022/12/13/twitter_trust_and_safety_council/

[15] https://www.theregister.com/2023/10/18/twitter_not_a_bot_fee/

[16] https://www.theregister.com/2023/10/16/esafetty_australia_google_x_noncompliance/

[17] https://www.theregister.com/2023/10/11/eu_threatens_x_with_dsa/

[18] https://www.theregister.com/2023/10/06/musk_in_hot_water_with/

[19] https://www.theregister.com/2023/10/18/twitter_not_a_bot_fee/

[20] https://www.theregister.com/2023/09/11/gates_musk_beef_biography/

[21] https://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-work-from-home-crowd-detached-from-reality-tesla-2023-10

[22] https://edition.cnn.com/2022/08/30/health/elon-musk-population-collapse-wellness/index.html

[23] https://whitepapers.theregister.com/



Best argument for rejoining EU

trevorde

So we don't have to suffer Xitter

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Lon24

Given that Elon wants X/Twitter to embrace payments and banking then trying to satisfy regulators around the world is worse than a nightmare. Dedicated banks have difficulty. Hence making X/Twitter a US-only corp has attractions if he wants to move fast and break things.

Not that he hasn't done too badly on that front so far.

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Yet Another Anonymous coward

>Elon wants X/Twitter to embrace payments and banking then trying to satisfy regulators around the world

That's the nice thing about being a dynamic hyper move-fast-and-break-things Silicon Valley company with a cool name = you can ignore regulations

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

MrDamage

> Hence making X/Twitter a US-only corp has attractions if he wants to move fast and break things.

> Not that he hasn't done too badly on that front so far.

I agree, He's doing a wonderful job of breaking things that weren't broken to begin with.

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Anonymous Coward

Perhaps the Internet could be improved by having two tiers of access: read only for everyone and the ability to comment/submit content for people who meet thresholds for IQ, tolerance and decency.

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Anonymous Coward

and the ability to comment/submit content for people who meet thresholds for IQ, tolerance and decency.

Do you mean people who are above or below such thresholds?

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Ken G

Below, obviously.

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

BebopWeBop

That would spoil Twatter/X for many

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Anonymous Coward

Why should the rights of those who want to parrot racism, homophobia and transphobia while helping Russia spread misinformation be respected?

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Khaptain

"Why should the rights of those who want to parrot racism, homophobia and transphobia while helping Russia spread misinformation be respected?"

Do you know anyone on this planet that does not fit into one of those phobias ? Can you prove to the rest of the world, and everyone that has differing viewpoints from your own, that you are neither racist, homophobic or transphobic ?

I would be that you can't because the very definitions vary depending on who you discuss with.

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Anonymous Coward

not sure about you, I don't have any of those particular phobias and my friends don't, why would I be friends with people with those phobias?

I am a bit claustrophobic due to some trauma early in life. but it manageable.

as for "definitions vary" there might be minor differences, but the basics are clear unless you talking about arseholes who try to pretend they aren't in those groups

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Yet Another Anonymous coward

Except for Emacs users, and Python programmers who use tabs, and people who put C braces on their own line, and people who but the desktop dock on the right, and Belgians

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Ian Johnston

I don't have any of those particular phobias

You are claiming categorically not to be racist, then? Are you white?

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Anonymous Coward

I don't have any of those particular phobias and my friends don't ...the basics are clear unless you talking about arseholes who try to pretend they aren't in those groups

Oh, the irony.

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Arthur the cat

Why should the rights of those who want to ${THING_I_DONT_LIKE_TODAY} be respected?

Because rights are supposed to be universal and apply not only to most virtuous saint but the biggest, most unpleasant arsehole on the planet equally. If they don't they're not rights, they're privileges.

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Anonymous Coward

now your falling into the tolerance of intolerance issue.

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Ian Johnston

Because once you start deciding who has rights based on whether they agree with you, you're halfway down a slippery slope and descending fast.

Re: Best argument for rejoining EU

Ian Johnston

I have long thought that Mumsnet proves how wrong it was to give women the vote ... while the rest of the internet proves how wrong it was to give anyone the vote. Well, except me, obviously.

Goodbye Elon, don't forget to shut the door on your way out.

may_i

The more I hear, the more I'm convinced that Musk is totally unhinged.

As for being 'detached from reality' by working from home - All my colleagues work in a town some 450Km away from where I live. Consequently, I spend every working day working from the distraction free comfort of my home. I frequently receive compliments on my work from my immediate manager and my colleagues and always meet my deadlines. It works perfectly for me and I know many others who work from home and enjoy the same great working environment and collaboration with their colleagues.

As the article rightly points out, the only person who is detached from reality is Elon Musk himself.

Seeing what is left of Twitter close down in the EU would be something I'd only know about from the press. I certainly wouldn't miss it!

Re: Goodbye Elon, don't forget to shut the door on your way out.

b0llchit

I was more thinking of "please let the door hit you on the way out" because it might expedite his exit.

--> Icon: One can only hope it'll happen sooner than later.

Hmm

codejunky

"This was particularly in light of renewed hostilities between Israel and Hamas, and the potential disinformation campaigns that had begun swirling online"

Only a few minutes ago I was reading about the media pushing about some hospital in Gaza being blown to pieces by Israel bombing and killing 500 people being incorrect. Apparently it was a terrorist rocket misfiring into the hospital car park and not even leaving a crater (dunno if it killed anyone).

Not defending X but as for media lies there have been a lot for a while!

Re: Hmm

Steve Button

Stay away from The BBC and The New York Times (and all the rest of them to be honest)

Or at least spread your news consumption across more platforms, including dipping into Al Jazeera and SubStack newsletters + others.

Although none of them seem to be saying "I support neither terrorists or war criminals", they are all on one team or the other.

As for Xitter, it's polarising but with the volume turned up to 11. Stay well away.

Re: Hmm

Jellied Eel

Only a few minutes ago I was reading about the media pushing about some hospital in Gaza being blown to pieces by Israel bombing and killing 500 people being incorrect. Apparently it was a terrorist rocket misfiring into the hospital car park and not even leaving a crater (dunno if it killed anyone).

Allegedly. But this is the problem with 'misinformation'. We don't know what happened there, and probably can't trust any of the official sources. IDF tweeted a post showing some images, but people quickly pointed out those were from last year, and IDF withdrew the tweet. But that's the problem with 'fake news' and propaganda during conflicts.

We know something exploded at the hospital causing a lot of casualties, but we don't know what or why. So there's been a lot of finger pointing, and some of the 'fact checking' has been rather implausible. Actual fact checking would require a proper investigation, but that's hard to do in the middle of a conflict, especially when there's also strong incentives to hide evidence. It's been the same situation with the Ukrainian conflict where claims of deliberate missile strikes on civilian targets have turned out to be errant air defence missiles.

Stuff happens, accidents happen, but unless they're investigated properly, trust in the media and governments declines.. Not that there's much trust to begin with.

Re: Hmm

Steve Button

Prior to 2020 and Covid I had broad trust of western governments and mainstream news. I just wasn't looking closely enough, but now I've seen evidence of some of the lies and corruption it's hard to un-see it. They all seem to have a preferred narrative that they are following, and struggle to see both sides in anything. It's really hard to know the truth of anything, especially in the fog of war. When there's war involved it might be we'll never know. But war is big business for some. And wealthy donors get to sway corruptible politicians.

Pharma is also big business, but people don't seem to like me pointing that out.

Re: Hmm

Flocke Kroes

Big snake oil is far worse.

Re: Hmm

Anonymous Coward

"Big Snake Oil"? Do you mean Homeopathy or Supplements?

Re: Hmm

Yet Another Anonymous coward

>"Big Snake Oil"?

Jörmungandr = ever wondered why the Norwegians seem to have so much oil ?

Re: Homeopathy or Supplements

Flocke Kroes

Yes, and bee stings, ivermectin (unless you are a horse), real water, Goop products, church of bleach, ...

Re: Hmm

Jeff Smith

Whilst there is and always has been a degree of bias to the traditional news outlets (indeed it is impossible to be perfectly unbiased), a big part of the trust issue to my mind is that many people are no longer satisfied unless they’re being told exactly what they want to hear. It’s very easy to head off into the internet and have your biases confirmed. Cynical politicians exploit this.

Lurko

I think you'll find the UK's Online Safety Bill will be a similar problem for Musk, since it's got many of the same requirements as the EU's Digital Services Bill.

Let's see if he'll go ahead. If he does it'll force the Twitterati to find an alternative, given these people NEED an online way to express their vacuous thoughts something will quickly gain critical mass in Europe, and that'll be the end of Twitter/X.

Catkin

I'd take endless amounts of "vacuous" commentary being readable by those who want to read it over a bill that puts that much power in the hands of the state. That is to say nothing of the wider atrocities it will enable in time.

mpi

> that puts that much power in the hands of the state

I'd rather see that much power in the hands of states, than a megacorporation beholden to shareholders and super-rich individuals.

Anonymous Coward

>I'd rather see that much power in the hands of states, than a megacorporation beholden to shareholders and super-rich individuals.

At least it forces them to buy the politicians. Unless they are a media company - in which case the politicians have to pay them

Tesla's Q3 earnings call

Anonymous Coward

As the article notes, Tesla's Q3 earnings call was yesterday. And they were OK - by the standards of a car company they were good. They are selling a lot of cars, earnings were >$20Bn. But they missed the predictions by a tiny bit, and are they really good enough to justify the high share price? Who cares - Elon's shot his mouth off, and so everyone talks about him again. Oddly, this seems to keep happening every time there's some less-than-stellar news about Tesla.

Re: Tesla's Q3 earnings call

Andy 73

By the standards of a car company, a steady decline is "good" - car usage is dropping in most Western countries.

By the standards of Tesla, the results were a disaster.

Margin dropped 10% YoY

Expenses increased 44% YoY

Income from operations droped 52% YoY

These are some pretty terrible numbers. And remember: Tesla is meant to be growing 100% each year - that's the justification for the insane share price, so what happens when their stock has essentially been flat since December 2020? Worse still, Musk admitted in the earnings call that the Cybertruck is going to take 18 months to reach profiability (that's 18 Musk months, which could mean 10 years by past evidence). They're a car company that essentially has only one model.

Re: Tesla's Q3 earnings call

mark l 2

No Tesla isn't worth the huge amount its share price indicates which says its worth more than several other car companies combined that sell vastly more cars every year such as Volkswagen + BMW + Ford.

By all accounts even though Tesla cars are priced in the same region as luxury cars such as as Mercedes or Audi the build more like they are a mid tier priced car. Badly fitting panels, dodgy paint, cheap feeling interiors and loads of teething issues that mean they are often need to go back to the garage for repairs are often gripes that Tesla owner report after buying.

And then there feature such as 'full self driving' which is supposed to be rolled out with a software update to the existing cars. Which no doubt some thought it meant you can buy a Tesla now and in a few years you will be able to just tell it where to take you and then have a nap and wake up at your destination, but this is never going to happen as Tesla choose confusing terms such as Autopilot and Full self driving for what still amounts to just driver aids.

hittitezombie

Don't threaten me with a good time, Space Karen.

a bit rich?

EricM

Musk, of all living, er, humans, calling anyone or anything "detached from reality" is beyond ironic ...

TwiX being dead in the water is indeed a good thing IMHO, but I hope they get him out of Tesla and SpaceX before he causes damage beyond repair for those companies, too.

Re: a bit rich?

fajensen

I hope they get him out of Tesla and SpaceX

That's what they did by letting him have Twitter :).

Paul Crawford

I used to follow a few folks on Twitter but after the wall went up meaning you have the sign-up and sign-in simply to read posts i have not been back. So for me it is not going to be a disadvantage if Xitter is lost from UK/EU due to safety concerns, and it will make for an interesting exercise in business management for future students to ponder.

Popcorn time?

Great idea Muskie, go for it!

Potemkine!

Oh yes please do! Don't hesitate, go, go, go!

Re: Great idea Muskie, go for it!

Flocke Kroes

I think more effective comments might be: "Musk doesn't have the nerve to dump the EU." or "Musk lacks the technical ability to shutter X in Europe."

If/when no more X in the EU ... how should Thierry Breton ... "tweet" / communicate?

EvaQ

If/when no more X in the EU ... how should Thierry Breton ... "tweet" / communicate? He has 131.4K Followers

Reddit? Facebook? Can we have a vote / suggestions on this?

Re: If/when no more X in the EU ... how should Thierry Breton ... "tweet" / communicate?

BebopWeBop

Who is Thierry Breton?

Re: If/when no more X in the EU ... how should Thierry Breton ... "tweet" / communicate?

Anonymous Coward

Who cares?

Precedent voor other VLOP's?

EvaQ

Very interesting precedent if X pulls from the EU because of DSA: do other VLOPs consider the same? Or do they need the money, unlike His Holy Musk?

Please tell me

aerogems

What does the US have to do to get him to pull Twitter from that market? I will do absolutely everything I can to make sure it happens.

Re: Please tell me

mpi

Well, it's not as if the EU legislation is a secret.

The US of A are more than welcome to use them as a template ;-)

Who watches the watchers

scrubber

Misinformation? Like all the MSM screaming about Israel bombing a hospital?

Oh, not actual misinformation, just opinions the elites don't like. Got it.

Re: Who watches the watchers

Catkin

Sounds like you've had a little too much to think.

Process promptly.