Being declared dead is automated, so why is resurrection such a nightmare?
- Reference: 1657879205
- News link: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2022/07/15/something_for_the_weekend/
- Source link:
One such moaner is 58-year-old Michel from Montpellier. He has never stopped complaining since the postman delivered a letter one morning in June to offer him condolences on [1]his recent death .
It was, as you might imagine, an administrative error: someone had probably clicked in the wrong checkbox or filed a request in the wrong folder. It was unlikely to be the result of a concerted Kafka-esque conspiracy to erase Michel from existence. Uncheck that box, drag the file out of the folder. It should be easy enough.
[2]
Evidently not. Once you’ve been declared dead, it sets in motion a sequence of automated digital-only procedures that sprint towards completion with alarming rapidity. You may have heard of France’s notoriety for officious paperwork and the snail-pace of its bureaucracy when you are living and breathing. But once you’re a stiff, it’s the fast lane electrons all the way.
[3]
[4]
Michel discovered that his bank accounts had already been frozen. His social security file had been closed immediately. His national health ID card was no longer valid and his top-up health insurance was cancelled.
He nipped over to his local social security office to see if they could put the brakes on the process but apparently it was too late: everything had already been done to kill him off, bar physically shoving him in a box and inviting friends and relatives around for beer and sandwiches.
[5]
Surely there’s a rollback option?
Ah now, it’s not that simple. The system architect that designed the automated process did not think of making [Alive] and [Dead] a pair of either-or radio buttons. They did not envisage a situation in which death, our ultimate existential destination, could be reversed by choosing Edit > Undo. There are no second- or third-life Power-Ups IRL. Instead, the system architect not unreasonably assumed that dying would be a one-way trip from which nobody is expected to return.
The system is not a complete disaster, though. The woman at the desk of the social security office was able to use it to find that a French national with exactly the same name and birthdate as Michel had died – albeit 4,500km (c 2,800 miles) away in Israel – and the two strangers’ records had probably been mixed up by a poorly trained official. So the error has been located. Good. Can it be corrected, please?
[6]
Yes, she said, before booking him in for a meeting to discuss it in two weeks’ time. No doubt he was also asked to bring documents that explicitly state when he didn’t die.
It turns out that I live in a hot-spot region for those who are both dead and alive at the same time. In March, a retired gent in the Dordogne was [7]erroneously declared dead and it took him nearly six months to get his pension payments reinstated. His wife was told she had to write to multiple governmental agencies with copies of her husband’s Birth Certificate and the French bureaucratic marvel that is known as a Life Certificate.
I would advise every French citizen to carry a copy of their Life Certificate with them at all times. You never know when an official will ask you for evidence that you are not in fact dead.
[8]Youtube Video
In September last year, another retired couple experienced a more complicated problem. The husband died but [9]his widow was declared dead by mistake . She has been fighting to get this put right ever since. In October 2019, a retired man from Perpignan was declared to have died simultaneously with his wife, who passed away following a long illness. It took six months to "Undo."
In July 2019, another local fellow was faced with a double-whammy of his 37-year-old son dying and having to deal with the aftermath of an over-zealous box-ticker’s screwup who entered into the system that both father and son had [10]died at the same time . The bereaved father is reported to have said that trying to correct the erroneous declaration of his own death while sorting out the real one of his son nearly killed him .
This would certainly have been a satisfactory outcome from a purely bureaucratic standpoint and saved some systems operators a great deal of inconvenience over the summer vacation period. Indeed, it could be considered unpatriotic of the father not to have obliged in this respect.
There is a gentle irony in that the region in which I live is also renowned for people not dying precociously. The world’s current oldest living person resides here: [11]Lucile Randon , a long-retired nun who was born on 11 February 1904. The longest-living person ever recorded in human history was another local: [12]Jeanne Calment lived to be well over 122 before her death in 1997.
Given the region’s propensity for longevity, it is perhaps not surprising that there are so many erroneous declarations of death. I imagine that whenever an individual calls the local newspaper to insert a death notice, the Classifieds editor checks the age of the deceased: if they are under 100, he thinks, it might be an error.
[13]Confirmation dialog Groundhog Day: I click OK and it keeps coming back
[14]No more fossil fuel or nukes? In the future we will generate power with magic dust
[15]When the expert speaker at an NFT tech panel goes rogue
[16]A tale of two dishwashers: Buy one, buy it again, and again
What’s annoying, of course, is the speed with which the post-death bureaucratic operations are completed through automation fails to be matched with similar efficiencies in reversing them in case of a mistake. With so many of the latter being reported, more frequently than ever, you might think it would be worth someone’s while to reverse-engineer the system to add that so-far elusive "Undo" command.
My favorite tale concerns a landlady – again, in my part of the country – who had been moaning for years through every media outlet that would listen that she had been erroneously declared dead. But her story seemed incoherent and inconsistent, which is why I am not linking to it. Further investigation suggests that it might not have been so much an error by a civil servant as a parting fuck-you from a disgruntled parting tenant who had her declared dead after repeatedly but unsuccessfully trying to contact her for the refund of his deposit.
So if you were trying to think up an inexpensive and thoroughly modern IT-enhanced way to tip an enemy into the shit and have them wallowing around in it for months, even years, now you know. Don’t just announce their passing away, like an accidentally published newspaper obituary: tick the checkbox and make it happen .
[17]Youtube Video
Alistair Dabbs is a freelance technology tart, juggling tech journalism, training and digital publishing. He still stings from having to provide proof to the French authorities that he was not a bigamist prior to getting married. Most countries have such a thing as a Wedding Certificate but in France, there is also an official Certificate of Unmarriedness, and it is a right old bugger to find someone to draw one up when you’re not French. In the end, he persuaded a British consul to sign a letter stating that the aforementioned – a person he didn’t know and had never met – was, as far as he could guess, probably not already married, perhaps, maybe, I dunno, I hope not. The French authorities accepted it without further question. More [18]SFTW here . Other stuff at [19]Autosave is for Wimps and [20]@alidabbs .
Get our [21]Tech Resources
[1] https://www.midilibre.fr/2022/07/07/on-le-prend-un-peu-pour-un-imbecile-declare-mort-par-erreur-un-montpellierain-se-bat-pour-retrouver-ses-droits-10421388.php
[2] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_offbeat/bootnotes&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=2&c=2YtGPIN@n1M3wcfGFmKTvfwAAABM&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D2%26raptor%3Dcondor%26pos%3Dtop%26test%3D0
[3] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_offbeat/bootnotes&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=4&c=44YtGPIN@n1M3wcfGFmKTvfwAAABM&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D4%26raptor%3Dfalcon%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0
[4] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_offbeat/bootnotes&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=3&c=33YtGPIN@n1M3wcfGFmKTvfwAAABM&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D3%26raptor%3Deagle%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0
[5] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_offbeat/bootnotes&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=4&c=44YtGPIN@n1M3wcfGFmKTvfwAAABM&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D4%26raptor%3Dfalcon%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0
[6] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_offbeat/bootnotes&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=3&c=33YtGPIN@n1M3wcfGFmKTvfwAAABM&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D3%26raptor%3Deagle%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0
[7] https://www.midilibre.fr/2022/04/18/declare-mort-par-erreur-jean-claude-vit-un-enfer-plus-de-pension-de-retraite-plus-de-carte-vitale-10243494.php
[8] https://youtu.be/wzFmPFLIH5s
[9] https://www.midilibre.fr/2019/10/04/perpignan-mort-vivant-a-la-suite-dune-erreur-administrative-ressuscite-un-mois-plus-tard,8457560.php
[10] https://www.midilibre.fr/2019/10/15/declare-mort-par-erreur-apres-le-deces-de-son-fils-la-descente-aux-enfers-dun-heraultais,8479864.php
[11] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucile_Randon
[12] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeanne_Calment
[13] https://www.theregister.com/2022/05/13/something_for_the_weekend/
[14] https://www.theregister.com/2022/06/10/something_for_the_weekend_/
[15] https://www.theregister.com/2022/04/16/something_for_the_weekend/
[16] https://www.theregister.com/2022/02/25/sftw_shopping/
[17] https://youtu.be/RH8nfp5sD_s
[18] https://www.theregister.com/Author/Alistair-Dabbs
[19] https://autosaveisforwimps.substack.com
[20] https://twitter.com/alidabbs
[21] https://whitepapers.theregister.com/
In the UK we have the DVLA
Which makes any Frog bureaucracy look easy-peasy to deal with.
Just try to SORN / tax a car after death & before probate.
Re: In the UK we have the DVLA
Seems I dodged a bullet there, I couln't find dads paperwork, so just claimed ownership. Seemed to be fairly painless and quick.
I'm pretty sure I had both V5s in my name within 2 weeks...
Remember Dabbs - He'll be missed
Sorry Dabbs, you did not survive the last article. Your life was unfortunately ended by a stuck key hopping onto the lever of "shut off permanently" . You will be dearly missed.
We'll await your ghost to write any follow-up articles to keep the readership entertained. Please do so with maximum potential from beyond the grave. We're sure that your ghostly outfit will make you see over us and scare us all to hell. Very good luck with that.
Cheers - you will never ever have another hangover in your dead state!
Re: Remember Dabbs - He'll be missed
Often wondered if Dabbsy had a ghost writer.
A disgruntled parting tenant who had her declared dead
I can't wait for the Channel 5 series in which a team of burly undertakers rouse recalcitrant debtors in the middle of the night and demand they "get in the box".
Can't Pay? We'll Take You Away!
Yeah, and
I can understand how this use case escaped the scope planning, but how about this for cruelty by design?
When my father died the (UK) married couple's pension was stopped immediately, but it took 3 months to start my mother's single person's pension. And that is normal.
Re: Yeah, and
Having been an executor (unfortunate title in the circumstances) now on a number of occasions I am no longer shocked by the incompetence, petty bureaucracy and general lack of empathy shown by government departments, financial institutions and service and utility providers. In many cases you are obliged to deal with a small number of "specially trained" staff who have clearly all received courses in officious insensitivity and saying "no" by default.
Whereas death is fortunately a once-in-a-lifetime event for most of us, you'd think it would be sufficiently common that organisations might by now have worked out how to deal with it - at least efficiently, if not sympathetically,
Re: Yeah, and
When Dad died, one of the first things we did was to get BT to transfer the phone into Mum's name
Naturally the phone went dead on the day of the funeral!
Re: transfer the phone into Mum's name
It can help a bit if all such bills are - in advance of anything - put under both names, as a precaution.
Re: Yeah, and
I was once a line manager at a public organisation famed for process and bureaucracy. The smoothest and most efficient set of processes we had were those that kicked in when someone resigned, by a long way.
Err No!
"saved some systems operators a great deal of inconvenience over the summer vacation period."
Change the date of death, retrospectively.
Oh Yeah!
I'll bet you can't. Especially not to say you'd died after you'd already been declared dead .
What would happen if you committed a crime after being declared dead? Could they put a "dead" person on trial?
They did it with Martin Boorman, I think.
And at least one pope?
Don't forget that Charles II ordered Oliver Cromwell be dug up and then executed for Regicide. Did that change any death certificate or date of his death?
Ah no, hang on, I get what the question is now. Can you be declared dead and then go on to commit a crime with impunity?
I wonder if Paul McCartney did anything naughty after Abbey Road came out? "It wasn't me, luv, I was barefoot in Heaven at the time."
The Queen has been erroneously declared dead so often, she could have offed hundreds by now.
Mr Dabbs> ... she could have offed hundreds by now.
Could it not be said that HM's armed forces and SIS have done so for her on many occasions?
Catch-22
I love this! It's a real life enactment of Doc Daneeka's situation in Catch-22.
...Doc Daneeka himself came in about an hour afterward to have his temperature taken for the third time that day and his blood pressure checked. The thermometer registered a half degree lower than his usual subnormal temperature of 96.8. Doc Daneeka was alarmed. The fixed, vacant, wooden stares of his two enlisted men were even more irritating than always.
“Goddammit,” he expostulated politely in an uncommon excess of exasperation, “what’s the matter with you two men anyway? It just isn’t right for a person to have a low temperature all the time and walk around with a stuffed nose.” Doc Daneeka emitted a glum, self-pitying sniff and strolled disconsolately across the tent to help himself to some aspirin and sulphur pills and paint his own throat with Argyrol. His downcast face was fragile and forlorn as a swallow’s, and he rubbed the back of his arms rhythmically. “Just look how cold I am right now.
You’re sure you’re not holding anything back?”
“You’re dead, sir,” one of his two enlisted men explained....
...Colonel Cathcart refused to see him, and Colonel Korn sent word through Major Danby that he would have Doc Daneeka cremated on the spot if he ever showed up at Group Headquarters. Major Danby confided that Group was incensed with all flight surgeons because of Dr. Stubbs, the bushy-haired, baggy-chinned, slovenly flight surgeon in Dunbar’s squadron..."
Brazil
As I started reading this I was reminded of the opening sequence in Terry Gilliam's masterpiece (IMHO at least), and then saw the embedded clip.
If anyone hasn't had the chance to see it then it's well worth sitting down with a bottle or two (You'll need it) and immersing yourself in a view on the near future, as told by someone in the 1980's - yes folks, it's all about now, and it's horribly accurate.
For example, when Part P (UK wiring regs) first came out it was if they'd taken the script and applied it to the whole process: paperwork in triplicate, only 'qualified' people able to do seemingly simple tasks etc etc. I can't tell you how many times I wanted to do a "Bob Hoskin's Suit" on jumped up electricians.
Anyway, thanks Dabbsy for another fine read.
Re: Brazil
That movie was decades ahead of its time. When it came out we had no idea it was a documentary.
The solution is to find a way to earn money but not pay tax on it BECAUSE YOU'RE DEAD.
the government will fix the issue and add an UNDO option within weeks of finding out someone is gaming the system and not paying income taxes / has written off their credit card debts etc.
There only two certainties in life...
...death and taxes. Or was it taxis? What about Uber?
Musical choice?
Lemmy was a good choice, but surely something by Hotblack Desiato would have been even more appropriate?
Re: Musical choice?
By all accounts, a fine estate agent: https://hotblackdesiato.co.uk/
Re: Musical choice?
But his first choice was 'Gascoigne Pees'
Re: Musical choice?
I remember HotBlack Desiato used by kind permission of HotBlack Desiato on the record sleeve credits, confusing the hell out of me for years.
Just make sure there's a goodly life inurance policy in place and arrange a trusted person to be the beneficiary.
"This would certainly have been a satisfactory outcome from a purely bureaucratic standpoint and saved some systems operators a great deal of inconvenience over the summer vacation period."
That is a /wildly/ overoptimistic viewpoint.
The inheritance process if they both die at the exact same time and if the father dies later on are very different. The notaries involved would get quite busy untangling and correcting the process already under way. Depending on whether the father had siblings, and whether the child had siblings and children of his own, and how well they were getting along, it could easily take years.
In the UK if you both die within some period of time, the older one is declared to have died first.
This turned out quite useful in WWII, when some Lord and his son were killed in the blitz by the same bomb. The government claimed death duties on the father's estate then the same again on the son's.
I have heard of people writing into their will that their beneficiaries must live for 28 days or something past the passing to receive their bequest.
Found out when when I owned a company. We are married with no kids but partner is a few days younger.
If we were both in a car crash we assumed it all got split but everything would have gone to her elderly mother who would have become boss of a software company
Most countries have such a thing as a Wedding Certificate but in France, there is also an official Certificate of Unmarriedness, and it is a right old bugger to find someone to draw one up when you’re not French.
I had the same in Belgium... Trying to prove i wasn't already married involved applying for a marriage licence where i had previously lived in the UK, waiting 3 weeks for anyone to object, going back to get the certificate, getting the certificate countersigned by the UK consulate, getting it translated by an official translator, and getting that signed by a judge...
Proving you've never been married
>> Most countries have such a thing as a Wedding Certificate but in France, there is also an official Certificate of Unmarriedness, and it is a right old bugger to find someone to draw one up when you’re not French.
> I had the same in Belgium... Trying to prove i wasn't already married involved applying for a marriage licence where i had previously lived in the UK, waiting 3 weeks for anyone to object, going back to get the certificate, getting the certificate countersigned by the UK consulate, getting it translated by an official translator, and getting that signed by a judge...
Similarly when I was cashing in my Swiss pension and superannuation after moving to the UK, I had to prove I had never been married(!). Fortunately I was sharing an office with a Justice of the Peace at the time, so I made up a declaration that I had never been married, signed it before the JP as a witness, he notarised it, and within a short time I had enough money to buy a house here.
Re: Proving you've never been married
That doesn't prove you were unmarried, it's just you saying that!
If I went 'round sayin' I was Emperor, just because some moistened bint lobbed a scimitar at me, they'd put me away.
The Un-Dead
I used to do support on a patient record system (not NHS), in a hospice, so many deaths registered as normal day to day business, but the frequency that we would get support calls coming in because someone had been incorrectly marked as deceased was bordering on concerning. Fortunately, once you knew how it was pretty simple to resurrect someone.
"Further investigation suggests that it might not have been so much an error by a civil servant as a parting fuck-you from a disgruntled parting tenant who had her declared dead after repeatedly but unsuccessfully trying to contact her for the refund of his deposit."
This one is doubtful. You need a doctor's certificate or like in this article, a considerable fuck-up to declare someone dead. And the body of course.
But yes, it seems declared dead people actually fully breathing are becoming a meme in France.
Mostly, it's just there are likely, more than one "Michel Martin" in France, and some clueless idiot fail to conduct more verification and tick the wrong button.
Heck, my village has 2 postal codes, because it's big and 2 parts of the postal "service" are serving both parts. And they are in *different* departments, X and Y. My village depends on department X and my postal code is Y.
It shouldn't take a PHD to understand this is possible and my postal code is Y doesn't *mean* I live in department Y, but even postal people plus 50% of all civil servant don't seem to comprehend this.
Fuckwits.
My house is not registered in the borough were the land it is build belongs to (not exactly a borough, but the local equivalent). Every time I need to sort something with an utilities company it's like going to hell and back
In the end, he persuaded a British consul to sign a letter stating that the aforementioned – a person he didn’t know and had never met – was, as far as he could guess, probably not already married
MrsO and I had to get one of these (each) from our respective embassies in Thailand so we could get married, took a day from both the UK and Indonesia's, then a day to get them translated, then a couple of hours to get dispensation from the Thai Foreign Affairs ministry to actually get married. And off we trotted to a registry office that was used to foreigners, 17 years ago :o)
"We never make mistakes"
To cover such blunder the Bureaucracy found the best solution was to push those people to commit suicide
Now that Mr. Dabbs is a distinguished guest of this country, I would suggest him to have a look to the work of [1]Georges Courteline . One century later, his epic descriptions of idiotic bureaucracy are still valid.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georges_Courteline
Re: "We never make mistakes"
How do you record the death of someone who is already marked dead? It's no use to correct one mistake and leave an inaccurate death date in the database. You would probably have to change the death record to accept multiple dates.
Re: "We never make mistakes"
You must not kill the one who is already dead.
Re: "We never make mistakes"
Used to be a thing in the middle ages (and probably in France today) if you had the sacrament of "last rights" and then recovered you were considered "sort of dead" by the church and had to fast and be in mourning for yourself for the rest of your life
This report came to mind
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-brain-tiny/tiny-brain-no-obstacle-to-french-civil-servant-idUSN1930510020070720
Killed by Death
Probably my favourite Motorhead song. I remember reading an interview with Wurzel (late Motorhead guitarist who co-wrote the song) in Raw magazine years ago and he said he wanted it played at his funeral. I hope he got his wish.
Precogs help
In the UK, 'lasting power of attorney' basically gives you total control over an incapacitated person's affairs and, well... life.
If that person is very rich, and then gets better, (unlikely, but we're in that territory) - and you alone know, what do you do?
And even if you choose to do the right thing, try finding the Rollback command for that. You're more likely to be Committed.
I've got a Minority Report vibe goin' on...
The title is optional
Years back, when I got junk mail with a self-addressed prepaid envelope, I'd circle my name and address, write REMOVE FROM LIST next to it, and send it back to the offending organization.
Some didn't pay any attention, of course. So I took to writing DECEASED -- REMOVE FROM LIST (which horrified my wife and my mother, but was more effective.) I still got offers for pre-approved credit cards; apparently, death wasn't enough to make me a credit risk.
Only later did it occur to me that if I ever do need to take out a loan, I'll probably be told : "Sorry, Mr. Gray, but our records indicate that you're dead."
Re: The title is optional
>if I ever do need to take out a loan, I'll probably be told : "Sorry, Mr. Gray, but our records indicate that you're dead."
You don't think being dead would stop the bank trying to sell you a loan?
Ah Mr Gray, since you are already dead we assume the term of this loan will 'eternity' with a typical APR of ....
Thoughts
This recalls a bit of Flann O'Brien, with Sir Myles Na Copaleen returning from the grave to distress his supposed widow, heirs, etc.
Also, wasn't there a nasty train wreck some years ago near London, in the aftermath of which various persons took it upon themselves to declare that others had died in the wreck--disgruntled spouses, partners, what have you?
Proving that you are not a bigamist
Ah, the Certificat de Coutume! As an Irish person living abroad I was told that I had to provide one to the German authorities. This didn't apply to everyone, just Irish citizens and seems to be some sort of throwback to having to get permission from the church to marry. The Irish government website said that it could take up to two months to arrive, the requirements were not well documented and despite having sorted out the required paperwork while back in Ireland, was then told that I had to re-do them in Germany, my country of residence. Complete load of crap. The stupid bit of paper did actually turn up after two weeks (after re-submission) and not two months, but by that point we'd had enough and said fuck it, 'living in sin' is just fine thank you!
Getting a full rental caution/deposit refunded?
You'll be dead of old age waiting for that to ever happen.