News: 1636354691

  ARM Give a man a fire and he's warm for a day, but set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life (Terry Pratchett, Jingo)

Reg scribe spends 80 hours in actual metaverse … and plans to keep visiting

(2021/11/08)


I've spent rather a lot of time lately in an online environment that nails the Oxford Dictionary's definition of a metaverse – "a virtual-reality space in which users can interact with a computer-generated environment and other users" – and I find it so useful I expect to visit it frequently in future.

Is this thing a metaverse?

My metaverse of choice, in which I've spent more than 80 hours over the last four months, is called [1]Zwift – a virtual environment that recreates cycling or running with an interface a lot like a first-person shooter.

For cyclists, Zwift requires an actual bicycle mounted on a "trainer" – a device that lets the pedals and rear wheel spin but prevents the bike going anywhere. A sensor is also required to measure the speed of the rear wheel, and Zwift asks players to tell the game how much they weigh. The game is at its best with a "smart trainer" that can also measure the cadence at which a rider pedals and how many watts they are producing, plus hardware to vary resistance applied to the rear wheel. The last item is key, because it enables Zwift to simulate riding up a virtual mountain by making it harder.

Trainers with all the sensors and dynamic resistance control start at around $500. Zwift also requires a PC, Mac or AppleTV (plus display) or it can run on iOS or Android devices.

Whatever device you choose, you connect it to your trainer with Bluetooth, then ride Zwiftly through simulated environments. You can travers cities and towns, sylvan glades, transparent underwater tunnels, the lava-filled bowels of an active volcano, and even the platforms of a London train station located about where you'd find real-world Waterloo – but which offers an exit that's a 40km shortcut to a famous climb in Surrey.

[2]

Riding inside the Zwift volcano. Click to enlarge

You can experience Zwift alone, in groups, or race other players in real time. The harder you ride, the faster you travel through the virtual worlds. The image above shows me on a solo ride, with a list of nearby riders to the right. The game lets you chat with those riders – but most of the time you're too puffed to use the keyboard.

The game never requires goggles or glasses – I use a PC and a 28-inch monitor. Third-party accessories are available to simulate steering or even tilt bikes to replicate the angles riders experience when ascending or descending – but that kit costs plenty. And it's not used by the vast majority of Zwift's three-million-plus users, who make do with the game's pretty visuals and real-time performance data.

[3]Chip makers aren't all-in on metaverse hardware yet – we should know, we asked them

[4]Get ready for full holograms and 6G while living in the metaverse, says Samsung

[5]The web was done right the first time. An ancient 3D banana shows Microsoft does a lot right, too

[6]Zuck shows Virtual Empathy by visiting storm-wrecked Puerto Rico in VR

Meta-what?

In case you've missed recent metaverse hype, the term comes from Neal Stephenson's 1992 novel [7]Snow Crash , which used the term to describe a goggle-mediated multi-user virtual reality into which users can code discrete environments and gather to do almost anything.

Earlier this year, Korea's big tech players [8]decided to build one in the hope locals would use it to attend conferences and concerts.

Two weeks ago, Facebook decided its destiny is to [9]build and operate a metaverse. Founder Mark Zuckerberg described what he wants to build as conveying "a feeling of presence – like you are right there with another person or in another place" and suggested we'll be able to manifest as holograms in physical spaces, or perhaps experience shared virtual spaces that he illustrated with a video that looked cribbed from the [10]film adaptation of Ernest Cline's novel [11]Ready Player One .

Microsoft has also added metaverse-ish features to [12]Teams . It's definitely going mainstream.

I think Zwift nails the Oxford definition of a metaverse because the game imposes its reality upon your real-world effort. You simply can't get anywhere without putting out the power required to propel a rider of your mass from virtual point A to virtual point B. Cycling authorities therefore recognise Zwift as a sufficiently rigorous environment for professional races (and have even [13]sanctioned cheats who fudge their data to improve performance).

With the addition of a real-time voice service to connect participants, Zwift hits the Zuckerbergian definition of a metaverse by allowing participants to hear one another puffing as they all hit virtual hills.

Why ride in VR?

I started using Zwift during Sydney's June–October 2021 COVID lockdown because gyms were closed and time spent outdoors was restricted. Zwift offered longer and more satisfying rides, and the chance to replicate one of my favourite activities. The game's training programs offered just the goal-oriented activities I needed as July smeared into Locktember.

Since lockdown ended I'm Zwifting about twice a week for an hour or more each time – rather more hard riding than I did before I started. And I've just signed up for another virtual training program to get ready for a cycling event in the real world.

[14]

I'm using Zwift for that training because the game is convenient and avoids the messy and dangerous parts of cycling. On Zwift I can be halfway up a mountain half an hour after waking up, without stopping at a red light or dodging big-city traffic. That traffic means most cyclists head out early. On Zwift I can ride anytime.

[15]

A nice flat bit of Zwift's main virtual world, "Watopia". Click to enlarge

In conversation with bike club teammates and fellow Zwift users, my sentiments seem common. One clubmate, Ben, also agreed that Zwift is more convenient than real-world cycling and that the game's structured workouts can build fitness and endurance more effectively than riding in the real world. He added the observation that Zwift marries two of his passions – cycling and gaming – but feels the game isn't a great substitute for real-world racing. "Zwift is Mario Kart," he told me. He described a Zwift rival's racing as closer to Gran Turismo – a racing sim that tries to replicate actual cars and tracks more faithfully than Nintendo's kart-racing game.

Another cycling clubmate, Douglas, also appreciates Zwift as a training aide but finds it most useful when he also uses Discord to chat with friends while on virtual rides. He even goes on virtual Zwift rides with a friend in Canada.

[16]

[17]

"I'm not enamoured of the fake scenery," he told The Register . Instead, it's the chance to train hard without risk – and to socialise – that make the experience a part of his life.

US Army slows ~$20bn project to put Microsoft's HoloLens VR headsets into the field [18]READ MORE

Doug also opined that Zwift could be a guy thing. He told your correspondent he's heard the theory that "Men have side-by-side relationships, women have face-to-face relationships". Cycling in the real world is definitely side-by-side, and Doug feels that COVID lockdowns saw Zwift emerge as a replacement for that social experience.

Will Zwift stick?

Our collective experience of the metaverse suggests these things could take off – if they make an existing experience more social and/or more convenient.

Virtual reality has already proven this. I'm aware, for example, of VR and haptic feedback being used to [19]train student dentists how to administer injections, while architects and CAD types use it to experience their designs without the need for any real-world construction.

But I've never seen VR take off for entertainment, despite endless attempts at virtual presentations of concerts or other events.

[20]

Yet if I'm right, and Zwift is as good as it gets, I think metaverses will be very popular. If they improve on Zwift, things could get really interesting. ®

Bootnote : For any readers interested in a Reg -reading Zwift meetup, feel free to [21]e-mail me your Zwift ID so I can link to you. I've changed my Zwift handle to "Simon Sharwood – DHBC Vulture" if that helps. I'll aim for rides early in the UK morning and/or evenings on the US West Coast.

Get our [22]Tech Resources



[1] https://www.zwift.com/eu

[2] https://regmedia.co.uk/2021/11/08/screenshot_zwift_volcano.jpg

[3] https://www.theregister.com/2021/11/05/chip_makers_metaverse/

[4] https://www.theregister.com/2021/10/28/samsung_previews_6g/

[5] https://www.theregister.com/2021/08/11/column_cyberbanana_windows/

[6] https://www.theregister.com/2017/10/10/mark_zuckerberg_vr_visit_to_puerto_rico/

[7] https://www.nealstephenson.com/snow-crash.html

[8] https://www.theregister.com/2021/07/14/sk_telecom_ifland_metaverse/

[9] https://www.theregister.com/2021/10/29/zuckerberg_meta_facebook/

[10] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cSp1dM2Vj48

[11] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ready_Player_One

[12] https://www.theregister.com/2021/11/02/microsoft_ignite/

[13] https://www.theregister.com/2021/02/02/zwift_suspends_digital_dopers/

[14] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_software/front&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=2&c=2YYlXwro0-NBTGX6sTi1ALAAAAA0&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D2%26raptor%3Dcondor%26pos%3Dtop%26test%3D0

[15] https://regmedia.co.uk/2021/11/08/screenshot_zwift.jpg

[16] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_software/front&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=4&c=44YYlXwro0-NBTGX6sTi1ALAAAAA0&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D4%26raptor%3Dfalcon%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0

[17] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_software/front&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=3&c=33YYlXwro0-NBTGX6sTi1ALAAAAA0&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D3%26raptor%3Deagle%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0

[18] https://www.theregister.com/2021/10/15/us_army_delays_microsoft_ivas_vr_project/

[19] https://www.itnews.com.au/news/newcastle-dental-students-practice-with-vr-needles-to-spare-patients-pain-514794

[20] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_software/front&sz=300x50%7C300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251%7C300x252%7C300x600%7C300x601&tile=4&c=44YYlXwro0-NBTGX6sTi1ALAAAAA0&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D4%26raptor%3Dfalcon%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0

[21] mailto:simon.sharwood@sitpub.com

[22] https://whitepapers.theregister.com/



Second Life

AMBxx

Is 2nd Life still going? This appears to be the same thing with better graphics.

Re: Second Life

Anonymous Coward

But at least Sadville had lots of flying willies. Allegedly.

https://www.theregister.com/2008/11/21/reuters_sadville_end_of_an_era/

Re: Second Life

thosrtanner

Apparently: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-59180273

Re: Second Life

LordHighFixer

Worst article ever. Comparing SecondLife to Roblox or Minecraft. Sorry, but after 18+ years secondlife is still going. And the rest of the world is starting to catch up with it.

Next time don't interview a 4 month old NOOB. Grab someone who has been inside the entire time, ask them how it is. ((anyone in SL for less than a year, more like 5, is still a noob))

And if you are too much of a nancy to put up with a few flying penis, you should probably just turn off the computer, you are only going to get hurt.

https://secondlife.com/ you can still play for free.

Re: Second Life

AMBxx

I guess this is what happens to your after 18 years in 2nd life!

And it costs … ?

Detective Emil

€14.99 a month for us mainlanders. I'd rather spend that on ==>

What? What flight sim people are doing for ages?

LDS

Since flight simulators became "realistic" enough that's exactly what we are doing since many years ago, already....

Re: What? What flight sim people are doing for ages?

ssharwood

I think the word "Sim" undoes this argument. Zwift and its ilk measure the state of your body, and your real world body determines the outcome of the game, while the game places new demands on your body. But I certainly agree that the flight sim community has been social and networked for ages, and uses virtual recreations of the real world.

Re: What? What flight sim people are doing for ages?

AMBxx

Flight Sims have the same demands on your body as flying a plane - you sit in a comfy chair looking at screens for hours on end.

Re: What? What flight sim people are doing for ages?

LDS

Any "metaverse" is actually a SIMulation. Actually, as most flight sims do recreate the real world, and let you go anywhere - you're not bound to a pre-defined track - they are better simulations.

To my knowledge, nobody made a model of the Gossamer Albatross or the like still, so it's a bit difficult to make any use of devices designed to pedal on a bycicle.

Still good flight sim apply to the plane most of the real forces - including those from weather conditions and mechanical stresses.

Some support force-feedback controls, although those kind of controls never became mainstream because of the costs to make really good ones.

Sure, they cannot replicate forces applied to your body without expensive mechanical devices - but that's true for most of those real world replicas. You won't get acceleration forces from this bike simulator too - nor weather (or you won't cycle inside a volcano....)

Re: What? What flight sim people are doing for ages?

Disgusted Of Tunbridge Wells

Are you suggesting that this "game" should introduce a pedal powered plane and plug it into MS Flight Sim?

Anonymous Coward

Is this the new Zuck empire?

Anonymous Coward

Thankfully not. If cockbook ever borg it I'm off.

Metaverse?

Filippo

By that definiton, almost any online game is a metaverse? I don't think that's what Zuckerberg is talking about.

Re: Metaverse?

Gordon 10

Zuckerborgs definition includes a bit where he controls what you see to flood it with ads. Like most of the Tech Bro's he's failed to understand that Snowcrash was a cautionary tale not an instruction manual.

wiggers

Is there a version for eBikes?

Asking for a friend...

Gordon 10

It's perfectly fine to use an e-bike but a bit pointless unless its the only bike you own. The effort you put in is electronically adjustable with the cursor keys anyway so if whizzing up hills floats your boat - knock yourself out on a normal bike. The only time power is checked as mentioned in the article is on the Virtual racing circuit - there you would get banned for power doping.

Chris G

Aside from the exercise, the main joy of using my bike is being out in the fresh air, enjoying the scenery and riding in new places.

I realise Zwift has come into its own in lockdown but for me would be a very poor substitute.

In the house I use a cross trainer and loud speedcore, industrial core or a bit of thrash metal to spur me on.

Gordon 10

It's a compliment - not a substitute - it lets you do MORE or an equal amount of cycling regardless of the weather or the time of day. You can literally wander downstairs in your jimjams on a freezing/rainy/pitch black day and do an hour or more of a workout in your own home.

If you are into the training/enhancing your fitness side of things you can work in a far more controlled environment where there is no wind and an inconvenient hill doesn't show up right in the middle of your 110% effort.

It's also pretty cost effective - base model trainers with bluetooth controlled resistance start at £500 and include in-built power measurement which is considered the gold standard for cycle training. There are only a few powermeters for bikes that come in under that - most being in the 500-1000 range. Obviously you have to add in a bike and a laptop/tablet/AppleTV but keen cyclists are likely to have both those already. A keen cyclist will probably spend similar amounts on their kit to a keen gamer to put it into perspective.

Jay 2

For me also it's not a replacement but compliment. I use it during the winter or inclement weather (I'm a very fair weather cyclist!) just to get some kms in and usually do a lot more work than I would do outside. Also I get back pain when I ride outside, not so much inside.

Also as other say, sometimes it's easier to motivate yourself to do an indoor thing than to get everything ready for outdoors and then deal with weather, road surface, traffic etc.

The payoff is when it's (briefly) nice and sunny I can go outside and cycle around various terrains without too many problems... unlike one of my somewhat less fit friends who tend to struggle a lot more.

Travel through the virtual worlds

Warm Braw

One of the reasons our roadsides are littered with trash is that drivers perceive the artificial private world inside their car as more real and important than the actual world outside and hence they'll just chuck stuff out of the window to ensure their personal environment remains attractive without really considering the consequences.

There probably is something genuinely "meta" about an increasing number of people cocooned in virtual worlds while the actual world burns or drowns just beyond their peripheral vision. But not in a good way.

Re: Travel through the virtual worlds

John Brown (no body)

"There probably is something genuinely "meta" about an increasing number of people cocooned in virtual worlds while the actual world burns or drowns just beyond their peripheral vision. But not in a good way."

Now, if we can convince these people to use their imaginations, while attaching their static bikes to generators to produce electricity, maybe fit the meat-sacks with feeding and evacuation tubes...

Which pill will you take?

Zwiftbook

steelpillow

I have it on bad authority that Facebook Meta is buying Zwift and all its virtual routes will soon be sprouting advertising billboards -- with clickbait "manage this ad" buttons opening drop-down lists of preferred ads. :(t)roll:

Re: Zwiftbook

DJV

A good reason to cycle straight into the volcano*.

* Real or virtual...

ugh.

Omnipresent

This is not a game kids. You've made the real world so unbearable you have to escape in the very companies that destroyed your world in the first place. You cannot take away what you put into their servers... it never goes away.... not until the sun eats the earth. Every time you breath it's being collected and databased to create a virtual life form. All so you can play God. You are being bought and sold like cattle.

Re: ugh.

ArrZarr

Yes, because it's the "kids" that made the world this unbearable.

Re: ugh.

John Brown (no body)

Everyone was a kid once. Some have grown taller but are still kids. And some of those tall kids are the ones building Dystopia.

Ah, the depressing second phase of a tech hype

Howard Sway

After the first phase of the wow-look-at-the-amazing-new-thing launch, we then reach stage two where everybody attempts to shoehorn their existing thing into the amazing new thing, explaining that their existing thing was really the new thing, before the new thing.

This is especially easy with this metaverse rubbish, because it is really nothing new, and is all encompassing, therefore there is a huge amount of existing stuff that can be hitched to the hype with little to no effort.

Re: Ah, the depressing second phase of a tech hype

W.S.Gosset

That's a bit meta.

Re: Ah, the depressing second phase of a tech hype

John Brown (no body)

That's a bit meta (tm) .

FTFY :-)

Sidebar description

PhilipN

Pretty much describes my life.

Gonna try Zwift for a dose of reality.

Potentially expensive

Stuart Castle

OK, some quick beermat maths..

Subscribing to this service requires you have a "trainer" for your bike. These start at £500. The service costs £14.99 a month, or £180 a year. However, you also need a decent PC, with some sort of decent display, because I suspect you aren't going to get the same "immersion" if you run this on a 13 inch laptop, and it may not be practical to heave a desktop PC to the bike every-time you want to use it. That's likely to cost between £500 and £1,000. So, your first year is going to cost you between £1,000 and £2,000 in your first year. Although that cost goes down to £180 per year after that.

That's still a lot of money to do something you can do for free in your local area, just without the pretty graphics and the vague feeling you are competing with someone you'll never actually meet. But maybe I am wierd. When I was going to the gym, I preferred to just listen to my iPod (which was loaded up with the bulk of my music collection, and hundreds of podcasts) and not have to deal with *anyone*.

Re: Potentially expensive

Jay 2

I don't know about potentially :)

As the old joke goes: "Get your kids into cycling and they'll never have enough money for drugs".

Cycling doesn't have to be expensive... but invariably is.

You don't need a super-duper PC to run Zwift. I run it on a 7 year old iMac. You can also run it on iOS/'droid phones/tablets and even AppleTV. Many people either put a portable device on a stand in front of them, or just connect to a TV.

Subscription seems to be par for the course for almost anything nowadays. You do have a good point about a suitable bike and trainer though. They don't start off amazingly cheap and just get more expensive.

Cultural Appropriation

sam.swanson@gmail.com

Let's not let Facebook/ Meta steal the name 'metaverse' - they are clearly attempting to associate their brand with this already established word and concept.

Why ride in VR?

xyz

Pr0n... Nuff said.

What is status?
Status is when the President calls you for your opinion.

Uh, no...
Status is when the President calls you in to discuss a
problem with him.

Uh, that still ain't right...
STATUS is when you're in the Oval Office talking to the President,
and the phone rings. The President picks it up, listens for a
minute, and hands it to you, saying, "It's for you."