News: 1610362988

  ARM Give a man a fire and he's warm for a day, but set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life (Terry Pratchett, Jingo)

Facial recog biz denies its software identified 'antifa members' among mob that stormed Capitol Hill

(2021/01/11)


In brief The facial recognition company said to have identified antifa members among rioters who ransacked Capitol Hill last week denied that its technology had ever done such a thing.

The rumour started in an article (since deleted) in Washington Times and was later spread by Matt Gaetz, a representative from Florida's fourth district and Trump supporter, after armed insurgents stormed the legislative halls.

[1]

In what appears to be a bizarre attempt to shift the blame from extreme Trump followers, the conservative-leaning news publisher said XRVision had spotted antifa members in footage filmed from the disaster. But the company [2]told Buzzfeed the Times article was completely false. Instead, it said its software had actually spotted neo-Nazi and QAnon supporters among the crowd.

New York City is thinking of auditing AI algorithms used in recruitment

Officials working at the The Big Apple's city council have put forward a bill that would require employers to notify candidates when their applications have been analyzed by software, and to subject those algorithms to yearly audits.

The audits are designed to make sure the algorithms are checked for any potential biases. Companies will not be allowed to sell their software onto employers without having been audited first. If they violate any of the proposed rules, they will have to pay a penalty to the council.

The bill was introduced last year and [3]first reported by Wired's Tom Simonite this week. Many experts thought that the bill was not strict enough and should make the auditing process tougher to ensure that vendors were being fairly assessed.

OpenAI's zero-shot image model, CLIP

OpenAI revealed two new AI models, but the image recognition model named CLIP appears to have made less of a splash than the GPT-3-based [4]DALL·E .

The company's researchers claim CLIP is more efficient at learning how to recognize and classify images compared to traditional computer vision models. Off-the-shelf systems have to be retrained to identify objects that they weren't originally trained to recognize. But developers don't have to go through all that trouble with CLIP, however.

Instead of being taught to just recognize objects from specific labels, CLIP is pretrained using pairs of images and sentences of text. This means the model is able to learn a "wide variety of visual concepts in images and associate them with their names.

"As a result, CLIP models can then be applied to nearly arbitrary visual classification tasks," OpenAI [5]explained in a blog post.

Jim Keller left Intel, two years later he pops up at an AI startup

Chip veteran Jim Keller – best known for his work at Apple, AMD, and most recently Intel (which he left in 2018) – has joined a Canadian silicon startup.

Toronto-based Tenstorrent, founded in 2016 by ex-AMD and ex-Nvidia chip architect Ljubisa Bajic, has hired Keller to be the company's president and CTO. Designing and manufacturing new chip architectures takes years, and the upstart doesn't have any products on the market yet.

The chip upstart wants to design the whole stack, the hardware and software to support machine learning models in the data center to the edge. "Tenstorrent was founded on the belief that the ongoing shift towards ML-centric software necessitates a corresponding transformation in computational capabilities," CEO Bajic [6]said in a statement.

"There is nobody more capable of executing this vision than Jim Keller, a leader who is equally great at designing computers, cultures, and organizations. I am thrilled to be working with Jim and beyond excited about the possibilities our partnership unlocks."

US ban on selling geospatial AI software to China extended to 2021

The US government has renewed a ban that prevents American companies from selling China software capable of training neural networks to analyze satellite imagery for 2021.

The [7]initial decision came into effect last year on 6 January, and will remain in place for the remainder of this year, a spokesperson from the Bureau of Industry and Security confirmed to El Reg .

Under the rules stated in the latest publication of the Federal Register, the department is able to extend the temporary ban for three years. It is in the process of determining whether the decision should be permanent, but officials have not been able to meet to discuss the issue safely due to COVID.

[8]

"However, due to the pandemic, the regime did not convene and therefore did not consider acceptance of the proposal. An extension of time is appropriate in order for the US Government to continue its effort at the Wassenaar Arrangement in 2021," the journal [9][PDF] said. ®

Get our [10]Tech Resources



[1] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_emergent_tech/artificial_intelligence&sz=300x250%7C300x252%7C300x600&tile=3&c=33X-yELMcdCOBVn0Ve5OuxQwAAAIY&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D3%26raptor%3Deagle%26pos%3Dtop%26test%3D0

[2] https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/craigsilverman/facial-recognition-antifa-washington-times-false

[3] https://www.wired.com/story/new-york-city-proposes-regulating-algorithms-hiring/

[4] https://www.theregister.com/2021/01/07/openai_dalle_impact/

[5] https://openai.com/blog/clip/

[6] https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/jim-keller-joins-tenstorrent-as-president-and-cto-301201505.html

[7] https://www.theregister.com/2020/01/06/us_government_ai_satellite_training_ban/

[8] https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?co=1&iu=/6978/reg_emergent_tech/artificial_intelligence&sz=300x100%7C300x250%7C300x251&tile=4&c=44X-yELMcdCOBVn0Ve5OuxQwAAAIY&t=ct%3Dns%26unitnum%3D4%26raptor%3Dfalcon%26pos%3Dmid%26test%3D0

[9] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2021-01-06/pdf/2020-28776.pdf

[10] https://whitepapers.theregister.com/

The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

Hubert Cumberdale

...is that "antifa" is not an actual identifiable thing: to these crazies, it's a collective name for anyone that disagrees with them and with whom they have decided they are at war (cf. Eastasia). They can then insist that whatever the problem is, antifa is the problem.

Re: The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

Doctor Syntax

Who needs AI when so many of them outed themselves in real time on social media?

Re: The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

Danny 2

"its software had actually spotted neo-Nazi and QAnon supporters among the crowd"

Not the proudest boast for the software, given the T shirts, signs, flags and baseball caps they were wearing. Plus, for extra irony, their lack of facemasks.

It reminds me of the 'Silicon Valley' program that could identify any food image as either "Not a hotdog" or "Hotdog".

Re: The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

Jellied Eel

Who needs AI when so many of them outed themselves in real time on social media?

One was apparently swiftly identified due to his wearing his company ID badge. Strangely enough, that person is now unemployed.

But I'm still curious about this chappie-

https://twitter.com/AmyMek/status/1347147785926103043

and what will happen to him. At least he was easy to identify after giving an interview on CNN..

Re: The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

MiguelC

well, a 5 second google search returns this... [1]https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2021/jan/09/facebook-posts/facebook-posts-wrongly-claim-left-wing-activist-an/

[1] https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2021/jan/09/facebook-posts/facebook-posts-wrongly-claim-left-wing-activist-an/

Re: The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

ratfox

Logic does not necessarily have to go into it. Even the Jamiroquai guy who posed on the podium of the Senate, who is a well-known and identified person openly advocating for Trump, has been claimed to be an actor [1]on the basis of him showing up once at a climate change event .

On a related note, [2]Jamiroquai has been trending on Google

[1] https://twitter.com/ShellenbergerMD/status/1347243232577523712

[2] https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=now%207-d&geo=US&q=%2Fm%2F046p9

Re: The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

chivo243

So true... Like so many people, they need a boogey man in their lives, some one to take the blame for everything out of their control.

Re: The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

a_yank_lurker

I would not trust the identification as the software is not the most reliable. The error rate both ways is extremely high for it be reliable for any use.

When using video/photo evidence one has to be wary of angles, lighting, camera settings, etc. that may distort the face. Also, how well the software discriminates between 2 people who strongly resemble themselves needs to be addressed.

Re: The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

DavCrav

"Also, how well the software discriminates between 2 people who strongly resemble themselves needs to be addressed."

True, but in this case it finds that a neo-Nazi bears a strong resemblence to someone storming the seat of government. So, you know, it is likely to be on the money.

Re: The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

martinusher

Unless these people walked from their homes, wore masks and did not carry cellphones then they'll have left all manner of traces. There's also another widely used form of facial recognition called "I know this guy" -- its also falliable but its been used in successful criminal prosecutions for hundreds, if not thousands, of years.

@Fellow Yank... Re: The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

Mike the FlyingRat

Its not a question of a single identification.

Take the ANTIFA idiot who claimed to be there documenting things when he was filmed breaking a window.

He was identified and his photo was compared and identified as someone out of Utah at both BLM and Antifa events.

So while single photos and events may be suspect, if you can limit the pool of offenders and then compare to photos taken at other events, you tend to be more reliable.

BTW, anyone who thought it was a good idea to march on the Capitol is an idiot.

If you're going to condemn those who support Trump you need to also condemn the BLM and Antifa rioters as well. (Which CNN and MSNBC have characterized as 'peaceful protests'. )

And for those who live on the eastern side of the pond think this is only an American issue, I can easily find photos of riots and police using water cannons in the UK, France and other countries. I seem to recall truckers in France rioting not too long ago...

Re: The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

Hubert Cumberdale

Funnily enough, I have a tendency to strongly resemble myself.

@Hubert Re: The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

Anonymous Coward

Err yes and no.

Yes ANTIFA is a loose knit organization based on a radical ideal and who's 'anti-fascist' tactics are more aligned to the Brown Shirts and fascist tactics which they openly claim to hate.

But I digress.

The important point is that the facial recognition software did in fact identify individuals who are openly on the left and support the use of violence. ANTIFA and BLM.

The only reason that they are denying this is that they saw what happened to Parler over this weekend.

I'm sure that this post will be downvoted, but smug gits who don't understand that beyond the 'Orange Man Bad' mentality, the values of which this country is built upon is being eroded.

We live in dangerous times and it will only get worse.

Not just in the US.

Check out what's happening in Hong Kong.

While I'm a Yank, you Brits handed over Hong Kong to China where they promised to honor Hong Kong's independence and democracy. Seems that ended over 2 decades too soon.

BTW, Where's Jack Ma?

And that my friend is the future of the US and other Western countries.

@AC - Re: @Hubert The main problem with trying to spot antifa members...

Anonymous Coward

Yes, you are a Yank, you're not good at history and yes, you digress. Brits rightfully returned a teritory they occupied long time ago during the Opium Wars.

Also if BLM and AF were the crowd that stormed the Capitol, the law enforcement wold have been there in military full combat gear, with drones, hellicopters and armoured vehicles as they usually do.

And to conclude, China has nothing to do with what happes in US so stop hiding behind "look they're doing it too". Let's face it, your democracy is scr$%?wd without any foreign intervention at all.

The coup explained in 5 easy steps

Anonymous Coward

The coup explained in 5 easy steps

1) Trump tries to force Georgia et al, to claim fraud and find more Trump votes on penalty of criminal case.

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/03/us/politics/trump-raffensperger-call-georgia.html

2) Republicans led by Josh Hawley & Ted Cruz, try to use Step 1) as justification for a 10 day audit of election fraud. Delaying the certification until 16th or 17th of January.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/profoundly-sad-moment-for-our-country-gop-senators-line-up-behind-hawley-s-effort-to-contest-the-election/ar-BB1cqcbF

3) Mob under direction of Trump, attack Capitol Hill, trying to force plot step 2 to succeed.

4) Second armed militia (pafa2021), planned for 16th and 17th January, plan to seize control of Capitol Hill, and only let loyal Republicans enter the building, so that only their Republican group gets to vote on the fraud claim.

https://web.archive.org/web/20210106072816/https://pafa2021.com/how%2C-when%2C-where

This armed militia was to seize control of Capitol Hill, act as armed guards for Trump in the Whitehouse, and seize the Supreme Court and several road junctions.

5) The coup-plot Republicans that Step 4 allowed into Capitol Hill, then vote the audit showed election fraud and pass whatever law they want to seize power.

A coup.

You can see the elements don't make sense individually, but put them together and suddenly its clear what the plan was/is.

Q. Why try to overturn Georgia, it's no enough for Trump to win? No, but its needed to justify the 10 day 'audit'.

Q. Why 10 days? the House and Senate would simply accept the result after the 10 days? No, because the pafa2021 mob was to seal off Senate and Congress so only their *loyal* Republicans could vote.

Q. Why did the pafa2021 have an attack planned for 16/17th, yet claim to want to stop the Inauguration on the 20th? Because the vote of the Republicans on the 17th was the main part of the coup, not disrupting the Inauguration ceremony 3 days later.

Q. How early was the armed militia planned? 4th January or earlier, i.e. before the Mob attack on the 6th:

https://web.archive.org/web/20210104150859/https://www.militia.me/

Q. Why plot an armed militia for the 16th and 17th, when its too late, the certification would already have happened on the 6th?.... Because they also have the mob planned for the 6th, and the 10 day Republican 'audit' delay to take it till the 17th! i.e. see the linkage between the groups.

Q. Where does Parler come in? It's where they discussed and promoted the armed militia:

https://www.google.com/search?q=links%3Apafa2021.com

Q. What would stop the National Guard from stopping their mobs? That's a question to direct at Christopher C Miller. Why were they not permitted to enter the capitol Christopher? They needed permission from your department, which didn't arrive.

Q. What would stop the Capitol Police from shooting their guys? That's a question to direct to Steven Sund. Why did some of your officers direct people into the building and open the doors Steven?

There was a little subplot that happened. Step 2 had failed, Mitch McConnell decided to disobery Trump and hold the vote anyway in the evening. Trump and Rudy tried to get one day delay. Rudy even did one of his calls to voicemail while trying to get Tuberville to delay the vote:

https://www.msn.com/en-us/tv/news/oh-rudy-giuliani-leaves-voice-mail-for-wrong-senator-begs-for-delay-to-biden-certification/ar-BB1cxytB

Not sure the exact sub-plot here, likely an appeal to the Supreme Court along the lines of 'delay the certification to calm this angry mob'.

Why did it fail?

Don't count your chickens before they hatch. It hasn't yet failed. Trump is still in power, there's still the Flynn coup attempt, and other coup attempts possible. Ted Cruz is doing his 'unity/healing' thing in public, perhaps he's selling them out, in exchange for a pardon in private.

9 days left, Trump is getting really really desperate. But there is no win scenario here, only coup *attempts*, each attempt more pathetic than the last. I cannot see a way he can win, only create more evidence.

At every stage of Trump's plotting, his plot has been predicted, investigated, mitigated against. But assuming he resigns and Pence gives him a pre-emptive pardon, you will only get the middle and little guys in jail for it. That's my expectations, Trump will walk way from this and leave others to face the time for his crimes.

Re: The coup explained in 5 easy steps

Hubert Cumberdale

I think you give them far too much credit for their organisational abilities.

Re: The coup explained in 5 easy steps

First Light

I disagree. Once inside, it only took 11 minutes for them to get to the House Speaker's Office. If the Prez and VP were suddenly to die, the Speaker is the next in line to take over. That's the power of that office. Remember that the Capitol was closed due to COVID and under renovation also. This means they had inside information. The FBI is investigating this.

Also, those in the House Chamber had zipties to imprison Congresspeople. They had gas masks, pepper spray, helmets and tactical gear. There were pipe bombs found in one car. They had set up a mock guillotine and a noose. Several had guns and ammo in their vehicles.

This was organized and there was collusion and a lack of resistance from Capitol Police. Black or Muslim protestors would have been shot en masse. Of course, they never would have gotten so far in the first place.

Re: The coup explained in 5 easy steps

Jellied Eel

Also, those in the House Chamber had zipties to imprison Congresspeople.

That claim seems to be mostly based around 1 person, who may have had the zip-ties to try and block doors.

They had gas masks, pepper spray, helmets and tactical gear.

Don't forget horns. As in Buffalo Bellend. But a lot of the images just seemed to show serious & organsed, violent coup conspirators just ambling around in casual clothes taking selfies. Note to those people: taking selfies in/at a criminal situation doesn't give you protection on any grounds of self-incrimination. It does however provide a grateful law enforcement a lot of good evidence. But anyway, a lot of that gear is just riot-chic, as modelled during peaceful protests in Portland, Seattle, Kenosha etc etc..

There were pipe bombs found in one car. They had set up a mock guillotine and a noose. Several had guns and ammo in their vehicles.

Yup. Obviously when you're planning to violently overthrow the government and instigate a coup, you leave your weapons in your car. Oops. But there were pipe bombs found outside both Democrat and Republican office buildings.. Which was a bit odd for a supposedly alt-right only coup. But much like with the selfies, law enforcement thanks protestors for making it easy to connect weapons to vehicle owners/renters. No doubt the ATF will be reminding a few people that the humble molotov cocktail is a destructive device, and construction/posession of such attracts serious jail time. Sometimes accompanied by a long stay in a burns unit.

But it's fascinating the way some people seem able to construct conspiracies out of half-truths.

Re: The coup explained in 5 easy steps

Anonymous Coward

So, here is the main group details for 16th/17th armed militia attack:

https://web.archive.org/web/20210104150859/https://www.militia.me/

Here was the pafa2021 plot for the 16th/17th January before their website was pulled. I think it's the plot Twitter refers to, when they mentions their traffic discussing another attack:

https://web.archive.org/web/20210106072816/https://pafa2021.com/how%2C-when%2C-where

It's also the plot they discussed on Parler, (links are rotting since the site was taken down, get what you can quickly):

https://www.google.com/search?q=links%3Apafa2021.com

"American Patriots organizing Nationwide on January 16, 2021. For PAFA updates please click here: www.pafa2021.com"

It contains a confession as to the crime they are about to commit:

""The estimated number of ARMED patriots needed for the PAFA2021 to move forward is approximately 15,000..."

So they planned to be ARMED.

"We will gather for 2 hours each day starting at 12:00 noon so that numbers can be assessed. If at 2:00 on Sunday 1/17 it is becomes obvious that the will to fight for America against democrat tyranny is not strong enough for the turnout to be effective, the PAFA2021 will be declared a lost cause and Joseph Biden will be allowed to be inaugurated. "

They planned to stop Biden being inaugurated if they could raise enough of an army.

"With a force of 4000 per location, we will encircle the grounds of each of the three facilities designated on this page. [Supreme Court, Capitol Building and Whitehouse]"

"The main purpose of surrounding the White House is to secure the grounds itself, along with President Trump, not allowing ANYONE in or out of the grounds unless designated permissible by the President himself on a one by one basis. "

That portion (them being his guards) requires Trump to be complicit.

"Encircling the Capitol building will ensure that no democrat politicians gain access any longer for legislation to be discussed with them. Republican representatives and senators will be allowed access to discuss legislation and continue business as usual without democrat interference. At each facility, the ONLY entrance and exit open will be the main doors in the front of the buildings. All other doors and entrances will be blocked with absolutely NO ONE going in or out through those doors. "

i.e. major crime, lots of jail time.

Whether or not they have 15000 armed militia, whether or not it failed, if you are party to this, it makes you guilty of the planned crime.

DO YOU NOTICE?

Without the Republican portion of this plot, Biden's win was already certified (on the 6th) and nothing they could do on the 17th would have any impact on the hand over of power. His inauguration was just a ceremony on the 20th, not even on the 17th.

Yet with the Republican portion of this plot, the ten day 'audit' that moves the certification back to around the 17th. Their circling of the Capitol building and only allowing in their Republican group to vote, *WOULD* permit the coup.

Republicans coup group, could do their fake claim of fraud, and reject certifying the result, and pass whatever enabling laws they planned to pass to hold power.

Notice also that this plot predates the Republican delay attempt in the Senate, here it is on the 4th January:

https://web.archive.org/web/20210104150859/https://www.militia.me/

See Ted Cruz, and his "healing and forgiveness" crap. Recognize this man is facing decades in prison is you can show his linkage to that second plot. This is true of all of the Republicans in this coup group.

Pick sides. Democracy or them.

I pick Democracy.

Re: The coup explained in 5 easy steps

DavCrav

"Why did it fail?"

In order to be a coup you have to not only pass laws, you need to be able to hold off the Army, who won't be particularly impressed at your coup. That's why most coups are by the military, or branches of them. Because if you don't have most of the military on board they won't recognize you.

The US armed forces swear an oath of allegiance to the US Constitution, not the US President. They serve him only so long as he is himself serving the Constitution. Obviously seizing the Supreme Court is not in keeping with the Constitution, so unless you have enough people willing to go along with the coup in the military, you will definitely fail.

Re: The coup explained in 5 easy steps

First Light

That's for sure and there are plenty of people of good conscience in the US military. But also note, the woman who was shot and died was a 14-year Air Force veteran (and a former member of the National Guard), one of those carrying a bunch of zipties to imprison Congresspeople was also a veteran and there were clearly members of the Capitol police itself that were sympathetic to the insurgents.

Re: The coup explained in 5 easy steps

First Light

Also, a PSYOP Special Forces Captain is being investigated for bringing a group from North Carolina to the rally. Note that Psyops are "operations to convey selected information and indicators to audiences to influence their emotions, motives, and objective reasoning, and ultimately the behavior of governments, organizations, groups, and individuals."

Of course, all those under investigation are claiming they never went inside and stayed outside. But most of them were trespassing there also.

Re: The coup explained in 5 easy steps

Hubert Cumberdale

That just goes to show that people of all sorts join the military. Having seen (against my will, I might add – damned Twitter autoplay) the video of her getting shot, she really should have seen it coming. Don't get me wrong: it's still a tragedy and she shouldn't have been killed if at all possible, but she surely should have realised what was about to happen. She may well have been spurred-on to walk towards several unambiguously aimed firearms by a sense of invincibility from not having been killed while fighting in other countries. In any case, she unfortunately paid with her life for having been twisted by insane conspiracy theories. To be honest though, I'm more bothered by the hundreds of thousands that Trump has killed by ignoring the virus, promoting lies, and generally being an idiot.

Matt Gaetz

Anonymous Coward

https://newsthump.com/2021/01/07/republican-congressman-matt-gaetz-blames-antifa-for-skidmark-attack-in-his-underwear/

Matt Gaetz

Pascal Monett

Supporting a politician is one thing, actively promoting violence and the refusal of the democratic process is another thing entirely.

I sincerely hope that every single person who is implicated in the shameful attempt at a "coup" will be apprehended and pay for their crime.

And I'm not just talking about the rioters - the politicians who endorse them are fair game in my view.

Re: Matt Gaetz

Rich 11

And not just the politicians. The Fox News and Breitbart 'journalists' who immediately gave out the Antifa line post-coup after repeatedly stoking the fires pre-coup should be obliged to demonstrate the truth of their more incendiary claims else face incitement charges.

Fact or Fiction

hoola

There is an interesting Andy McNab book, "Fortress" that is based on some geeks perfecting facial recognition. They are based in the US and have bucket loads of money from various sources. Various actions are then undertaken to destabilise the population so that they can then offer the technology as a solution to the "governments" problems.

The concepts are all there and increasingly we are seeing dubious organisations using the technology along with the inevitable "AI" to give it credibility.

Son, someday a man is going to walk up to you with a deck of cards on which
the seal is not yet broken. And he is going to offer to bet you that he can
make the Ace of Spades jump out of the deck and squirt cider in your ears.
But son, do not bet this man, for you will end up with a ear full of cider.
-- Sky Masterson's Father