Ireland unfriends Facebook: Oh Zucky Boy, the pipes, the pipes are closing…from glen to US, and through the EU-side
- Reference: 1599737108
- News link: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2020/09/10/facebook_ireland/
- Source link:
This is according to a report from the [1]Wall Street Journal , which said that Irish eyes won't be smiling come this Fall after a preliminary order to suspend data transfers to the US about its users was sent to Mark Zuckerberg's firm by the Irish Data Protection Commission.
The news comes in the wake of an EU court [2]ruling two months ago that transatlantic data protection arrangements - known as Privacy Shield - were "inadequate".
While last July's ruling did not strike down the Standard Contractual Clauses (SCCs) used as opt-outs by many companies, it seems likely that will come under the gaze of the courts before long.
Facebook rejects Australia's pay-for-news plan, proposes its own idea: How about no more articles at all, sunshine? [3]READ MORE
The ruling, it is said, would be particularly bad for the Social Network as it would require the company to silo off most of the data it collects from EU punters and keep it away from prying American firms governed by lax US privacy laws. Should Facebook fail to comply, it faces fines based on its revenues.
If the preliminary ban holds up - which by implication would apply to all EU member states - it could impact thousands of US companies.
It doesn't look like this legal wrangling will end anytime soon, as Facebook has claimed to The Register that it has the legal high ground.
Facebook spokesman Nick Clegg offered the following in response, referring to what he said were allowed standard contract clauses that send data from Ireland to the US:
"Like many other businesses, Facebook relies on SCCs to transfer data to countries outside the EU, including to the United States. Since the CJEU’s ruling in July, Facebook has been working hard to follow the steps set out by the Court to ensure that we can continue to transfer data in a safe and secure way," he said.
"This includes ensuring that we have robust safeguards in place, such as industry standard encryption and security measures, and comprehensive policies governing how we respond to legal requests for data." ®
Get our [4]Tech Resources
[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/ireland-to-order-facebook-to-stop-sending-user-data-to-u-s-11599671980
[2] https://www.theregister.com/2020/07/16/privacy_shield_struck_down/
[3] https://www.theregister.com/2020/09/01/facebook_australian_news/
[4] https://whitepapers.theregister.com/
is remote access allowed?
If the data was to stay in Ireland, does this prevent people accessing it from the US? It there is a web server in Ireland with access to the data, can someone in the US use a URL which points to that server?
Re: is remote access allowed?
Even if a Facebook staffer in Eire copies the details from a screen, and then whistles them in morse code down a transatlantic speaking tube, it's still transfer of data. The law is about data, not technology
"does this prevent people accessing it from the US? "
Oh well, under the CLOUD Act a US judge can still ask access to those data.
The main difference if for Facebook itself. As long as the data are in EU, it's far easier for EU to enforce its rules like GDPR. When data are transferred outside, it would become much more difficult.
Data "published" by the users themselves for other to see can be obviously accessed.
OT - "Facebook spokesman Nick Clegg"
My, how the mighty have fall... Hang on, that Nick Clegg? Really?
My, how the bloody useless have risen!
About time too
Well done EU. Too bad that we have left the club. ZuckFart will make hay here. Cleggy knows who to call to keep the LAw off their backs.
If you are in the UK and not on FB then you will be soon because BoJO will make it law.
Facebook aren't stupid while the EU probably is, it's not he transfer of data in question, as it is probably as secure as it can get, its when it gets stored on US Of A$$ servers is when your data becomes a free for all slurpfest and good luck getting EU laws upheld