News: 1597838476

  ARM Give a man a fire and he's warm for a day, but set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life (Terry Pratchett, Jingo)

Whoa-o BlackBerry, bam-ba-lam: QWERTY phone had a child. 5G thing's newly styled

(2020/08/19)


Because 2020 isn't weird enough already, BlackBerry phones are coming back. This time around, it's [1]not Chinese OEM TCL at the helm , but rather little-known [2]Texas startup OnwardMobility , which has acquired a licence to the iconic smartphone marque and plans to release an inaugural model next year.

Little about the phone is known, other than it'll support 5G, include a physical keyboard, and run Android. When probed by El Reg , Peter Franklin, CEO of OnwardMobility, declined to offer any feature specifics, but said the device would use a clean-sheet keyboard created in-house, rather than reuse a design previously used by BlackBerry (formerly RIM) or TCL.

Obviously, that leaves a lot unanswered. It'll certainly be interesting to see whether OnwardMobility retains the most popular features found in later BlackBerry models, like the capacitive coating that allowed users to navigate by swiping on the keyboard.

Sarah Tatsis, BlackBerry VP of Advanced Technology Labs, told us the keyboard design had not yet been finalised, but noted it will "reflect the brand values from a keyboard typing experience and input experience". Any device will also have to meet BlackBerry's internal quality and security requirements, she added.

BlackBerry Key 2 : Clickier, nippier, but how many people still want a QWERTY? [3]READ MORE

Another question mark hanging over the yet-unnamed device is what form factor it'll take, be that a slider mechanism similar to 2015's [4]BlackBerry Priv , or a more conventional "candy bar" design. While the latter will undoubtedly prove more durable, and will appeal to die-hard QWERTY enthusiasts, a slider mechanism will allow punters to better make use of any display real-estate.

Why 5G?

OnwardMobility has already landed a manufacturing partner in the form of Foxconn subsidiary FIH Mobile. This is familiar territory for Foxconn, noted Franklin, as the Taiwanese tech conglomerate assembled previous generations of BlackBerry devices following a 2013 agreement designed to stem losses at the then-struggling smartphone manufacturer.

"They have experience with keyboards, and they've brought a lot of ideas to the table for the feel of the keys, and the feel of the device in your hand," said Franklin.

OnwardMobility is largely aiming its upcoming product at government and corporate clients who wish to prioritise productivity and security – although it isn't averse to selling the phone to consumers looking for that increasingly elusive physical keyboard experience. Nonetheless, one has to ask: why 5G?

After all, BlackBerry phones have never really been regarded as entertainment powerhouses. Their oddly shaped aspect ratios hardly lend themselves to Netflix binges. And, as someone who owned every BlackBerry model released after 2017, I can definitively say that it's extremely hard to game when there's two-inches of keyboard in the way.

"We see a lot of enterprise experiences being enabled by 5G," said Franklin. "Productivity, along with security, is enabled by 5G in many ways. Your business executive running these mission-critical apps will benefit greatly when you have 10 to 100 times faster speeds with [lower] latency."

It's likely that OnwardMobility will target this new BlackBerry device in the premium "not quite a flagship, but not far off" category.

"Top of mind for us is not just making the most secure and productive device, but also being an everyday device," said Franklin. "That means things like a top-notch camera, and the other specs you'd expect from your day-to-day phone. Simultaneously, we know that we must be competitive, and so is our pricing."

Later BlackBerry phones manufactured and sold by TCL came with a bevvy of the firm's Android apps, covering everything from security and productivity to messaging.

The Register asked Franklin whether that would be the case this time around, although he declined to say. The company chief was also unable to confirm whether the phone would be included in the Android One programme, which guarantees a certain amount of software upgrades and security patches, although noted long-term support was one of OnwardMobility's "top priorities as a company".

Back in BlackBerry

The return of BlackBerry to the mobile sphere will be a welcome sight to some. The Canadian manufacturer all but dominated the smartphone space at the start of the decade, but quickly saw market share haemorrhage in the face of fierce competition from Apple and Google. Efforts to reinvent itself with the BlackBerry 10 operating system, which offered Android compatibility, largely failed to reverse that trend.

A reprieve came in [5]September 2016 , when TCL acquired the rights to the BlackBerry brand, ultimately releasing four devices: The Motion, KeyOne, Key2, and Key2 LE. That partnership ended earlier this year, leaving BlackBerry without a global device partner.

BlackBerry has also pursued a regional licensing strategy, which has seen it partner with device manufacturers in regions where it's traditionally performed strongly. That includes BB Merah Putih in Indonesia, and Optiemus Infracom in India.

In this market? 'They're going to need something extraordinary'

Can OnwardMobility restore BlackBerry to greatness? It won't be easy. One factor in their advantage is its executive team, which it said includes a crew with industry-specific experience. Its marketing lead, for example, has worked at the coalface with carriers and device manufacturers.

But, as CCS Insight analyst Ben Wood pointed out, it's a difficult time for the mobile industry, and the halcyon era of BlackBerry dominance is long gone. "The mobile business has never been harder," he said. "Add to that the headwinds of the pandemic, and the fact that the mobile market has dropped 12 per cent year-on-year.

"If you look at the space which you'd expect a BlackBerry device to occupy – which is more around the mid-tier, and not the uber-high tier like the Samsung Galaxy S20 Ultra – it's difficult to see anyone coming in, no matter what the offering is.

"Assuming they're in the £500-£800 space, they're going to facing phones like the iPhone 11, and devices packing six cameras and the latest Qualcomm chipset. That's a very, very tough space, and they're going to need something extraordinary."

Woods also raised questions about whether there was demand for a BlackBerry device. Most people have learned to live with virtual keyboards after all. The muscle memory required to use a proper QWERTY blower has likely long faded. Meanwhile, other manufacturers – most notably Apple and Samsung – have caught up in the security space.

"The addressable market has declined even further than when TCL took over the licence and there was enthusiasm from people still hanging on to their old BlackBerry devices," he said. "There was still that long tail of BlackBerry. Those people have since moved on." ®

Get our [6]Tech Resources



[1] https://www.theregister.com/2018/06/07/blackberry_key2_hands_on/

[2] https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/onward-mobility-d6e6

[3] https://www.theregister.com/2018/06/07/blackberry_key2_hands_on/

[4] https://www.theregister.com/2015/11/18/blackberry_priv_looks_like_a_keeper/

[5] https://www.theregister.com/2016/12/16/tcl_snags_global_blackberry_contract/

[6] https://whitepapers.theregister.com/

A beer for the headline alone.

yas1

Truly worthy of a Sunday Tabloid!

Re: A beer for the headline alone.

jake

The only question is, how long have they been waiting to use it?

Note: ElReg is a 7-day-per-week Red Top, not just Sundays.

anthonyhegedus

If they made it the right form factor, I can't see what is so inconvenient about having a keyboard. I haven't owned a blackberry for nearly ten years, but it is arguably more accurate to type on. The only problem is that either your screen real-estate is severely curtailed, or the phone is a funny shape. This is all so that you can view videos and photos in landscape mode. The problem is that the device looks dumb in landscape mode.

But if you're work-focused, type a lot of emails while you're out and about, and don't mind a strange phone shape, I think it would be useful. The secret to success isn't in the technical and design features, it's firmly in the marketing.

Michael Habel

A top secure device?

Then why the hell are you putting Android on it then? Oh yeah because actully building your own OS is actually harder then a rectangle with rounded edges.

An existing OS is best

RNixon

Because building your own OS is pointless because no one will support it.

Blackberry 10 was damned nice. But there were basically no apps for it except BB's.

Jolly good, I say

Kevin Johnston

As one of the minority that have never been able to use a virtual keyboard due to an inability to get the right key better than 30% of the time I say Huzzah! to the continual attempts to make a success of physical keyboard phones. It also helps that I use my phone for phonecalls/texts/email and little more so the fact the screen makes it impossible to watch a movie Netflix/whoever or play Fast & Furious 43 bothers me not a jot.

Re: Jolly good, I say

The Man Who Fell To Earth

Agreed. I loved my old Samsung Galaxy S Relay with it's slideout keyboard. I have a galaxy S20+ (and had a S7 before that), but I'd love a phone with a real keyboard again.

legless82

I still lament the passing of my Blackberry Passport - it's still the best device I've ever used even in the face of later Android and iOS kit.

Much as I'd like this to succeed, I can't see it doing anything except be a pale imitation and flop in the marketplace (much like the original, sadly). Through necessity, it's using Android, but the whole UI experience and ecosystem of Android neither expects nor particularly supports the use of a physical keyboard. The experience will be too compromised for most users to put up with.

Thanks for the laugh.

bill 27

Ram Jam, huh.

Re: Thanks for the laugh.

jake

I think you meant [1]Lead Belly . You can skip ahead to 1:05 for the familiar refrain if you don't like real music.

Manfred Mann's Earth Band released a version in '68, nearly 10 years before Ram Jam. I have a version of them (MMEB) doing the song live for John Peel on the BBC ... it is a bad[0] recording to cassette off the radio dated '72, digitized many moons ago.

For an up-to-date nod to the old classic, see [2]Mason Rack Band's cover ...

[0][ Bad is relative. It's better than some of the remaining examples of Robert Johnson's tunage, all of which is quite worth listening to ...

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SJUSGuNxt-4

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JJvd3vzJNDc

Re: Thanks for the laugh.

stiine

71...pff....Check these out.

https://archive.org/details/davidwnivenjazz

The sliders never had decent keyboards

Jim84

The Priv and all other sliders suffered from having keyboards with very shallow keypresses, they were a forerunner of the hated butterfly keys on the mac laptops in some ways.

I don't know how you could solve this problem without having either a gap at the bottom of the phone, to allow enough key movement, or an annoyingly big "lip" at the bottom of the keyboard. Maybe there is some obvious way to do this that my brain can't figure out. A lip that folds down when the screen is slid up?

One potential advantage - if you could slide the screen down to reveal a selfie camera (as well as up to reveal a keyboard) 100% of the front of the phone could be screen.

Even then, I don't know if there is much of a market for physical keyboards. If you want productivity on the go you'd be much better taking a bag and a ultrabook laptop or 2in1. Phones with keyboards fall between the two stools of "light entertainment device" and "productivity device/laptop".

karlkarl

My suggestion is:

If you don't need to put it online, just get a cheap ~£20 Blackberry Bold from CEX instead.

If you do need to put it online. Don't, buy a laptop instead.

A cousin of mine once said about money,
money is always there but the pockets change;
it is not in the same pockets after a change,
and that is all there is to say about money.
-- Gertrude Stein