News: 1592582648

  ARM Give a man a fire and he's warm for a day, but set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life (Terry Pratchett, Jingo)

Ex-director cops community service after 5,000-file deletion spree on company Dropbox

(2020/06/19)


A woman who deleted 5,000 files from her former company's Dropbox has been punished with community service – even though the business allegedly collapsed after her file-shredding spree.

Danielle Bulley, 58, of Tockwith in North Yorkshire, England, scrubbed her former business associate's Dropbox account after a company she was involved with collapsed and was resurrected without her.

York Crown Court heard on Wednesday how Bulley had spent five hours "permanently deleting more than 5,000 employee and supplier files and company manuals when she got into Letterbox Productions Ltd's cloud-based Dropbox," as the York Press newspaper [1]reported .

She was charged with computer misuse offences under [2]section 3 of the CMA 90 , prompting police to note: "This is an unusual case and a rare criminal charge – very few people are ever convicted using this law."

Bulley and her business partner fell out after their previous venture, Property Press (Holdings) Ltd, went into insolvency, the court was told.

Police alleged in a statement after the hearing that Bulley's actions had cost Letterbox Productions almost £100,000. Detectives from North Yorkshire's Cyber Crime Unit investigated and found that "someone using Bulley's internet address" had accessed the Dropbox account.

Detectives further alleged that during questioning Bulley had "admitted deleting the files, which she thought she was entitled to do but knew it would disrupt the new company." The victim told the court that his new company folded shortly after the attack.

"It was done in revenge," commented a merciful Judge Simon Hickey, who gave Bulley an 18-month community order along with 80 hours' unpaid work.

Police worker Steven Harris said in a canned statement: "Ex-employees can pose a serious risk to a business because they are familiar with the company's IT infrastructure and procedures. This can make it easier for them to carry out cyber crimes against their former organisation."

Bulley got off lightly. A similarly aggrieved ex-employee who exploited login credentials to target his former bosses [3]received five months in prison late last year .

In 2019, 57 people were charged with Computer Misuse Act crimes, of which a dozen were female. One of those women received a prison sentence compared to 12 of the male criminals. It follows that the majority of Computer Misuse Act sentences are so-called out-of-court disposals, where community orders and other means are used to encourage offenders away from computer criminality. ®

Sponsored: [4]Free Hands-on Training: Kubernetes in Google Cloud



[1] https://www.yorkpress.co.uk/news/18524143.businesswomans-computer-hacking-revenge-ruined-firm/

[2] http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1990/18/section/3

[3] https://www.theregister.com/2019/12/18/jet2_hacker_scott_burns_prison_sentence/

[4] https://go.theregister.com/tl/1956/-9042/free-hands-on-training-kubernetes-in-google-cloud?td=wptl1956

So... the headline should be

Hubert Cumberdale

"Company learns hard lesson about eggs and baskets, woman slapped on wrist for exploiting their stupidity"

Backups? We've heard of them...

Version 1.0

They were stashing corporate data in the Cloud with no backups, I assume that the Judge may have had something private to say about that - it would explain the decision.

There are two types of users in the world; Those who have lost their data, and those who are going to lose their data.

Re: Backups? We've heard of them...

chivo243

yes! only users lose data! So do some Admins, but they'll never admit to it!

Re: Backups? We've heard of them...

logicalextreme

Yeah, that's the only reason I can think of for such a sentence (based on the available information). As I'm sick and tired of explaining to employers — if you don't change the locks on your house when you move in, you can't reasonably expect all of your stuff not to disappear irrecovably; and saying "but it's illegal to steal" does not absolve you of some responsibility for the result if you choose not to do so anyway.

Re: Backups? We've heard of them...

DemeterLast

Are you a moron or something? Everybody knows that once your data is in The Cloud it is bathed daily with warm glacial spring water and groomed by a handsome centaur with a unicorn tail brush.

The Cloud is perfect. The Cloud is reliable. The Cloud is redundant. The Cloud cured my aunt's gout.

Sentencing

Nunyabiznes

So, should the male defendants get consideration for lesser sentences or should more of the women get prison? All in the interest of equality.

Re: Sentencing

Anonymous Coward

See also convictions for sexual offences...

more to this story?

chivo243

Defendant, a director, had access to documents in a in her old partners new company?

Crikey!

Mr Dogshit

An "internet address". Sounds terribly technical.

"Pages one and two [of Zaphod's presidential speech] had
been salvaged by a Damogran Frond Crested Eagle and had
already become incorporated into an extraordinary new form
of nest which the eagle had invented. It was constructed
largely of papier mache and it was virtually impossible for
a newly hatched baby eagle to break out of it. The Damogran
Frond Crested Eagle had heard of the notion of survival of
the species but wanted no truck with it."

- An example of Damogran wildlife.