News: 1592377024

  ARM Give a man a fire and he's warm for a day, but set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life (Terry Pratchett, Jingo)

Boffins find that over nine out of ten 'ethical' hackers are being a bit naughty when it comes to cloud services

(2020/06/17)


Infosec pros and hackers regularly abuse cloud service providers to conduct reconnaissance and attacks, despite efforts by cloud providers to limit such activity.

In a recent research paper titled "Cloud as an Attack Platform"

[1]PDF

, five boffins from Texas Tech University – Moitrayee Chatterjee, Prerit Datta, Faranak Abri, Akbar Siami-Namin, and Keith Jones – describe a series of interviews they conducted with computer security pros attending the Black Hat and DEF CON conferences.

Of the 75 security professionals and hackers they spoke with as a part of a larger examination of attacker psychology, more than 93 per cent admitted to abusing cloud services to create attack environments and launch attacks.

"We observed that these professional hackers often employ common strategies to abuse the cloud platform for its resource-efficient features in order to remain stealthy and silent while probing target machines, collecting victim data, discovering vulnerabilities, and launching attacks," the paper explains.

"We did not collect any demographic data, so we can not tell apart an ethical hacker/pen-tester or malicious hackers," said Chatterjee, a doctoral candidate and corresponding author, in an email to The Register . "Moreover, at conferences like DEF CON, participants do not get a name tag, we all got a tag that says 'human.'"

Chatterjee said recruiting participants to answer questions was difficult because they were afraid of being subject to a social engineering attack. "Some of them even thought we were stealing biometric data when offered them a pen to scribble down their thoughts using some diagram," she said.

Those using cloud services for offensive operations, the researchers say, have a common pattern. They set up a Virtual Private Server (VPS) or a multi-hop Virtual Private Network (VPN) to communicate securely with virtual machines (VMs) and load them with the cybersecurity tools like NMap, Metasploit, and Wireshark so they can conduct offensive operations.

Though infrastructure-as-a-service providers try to avoid this through VM network quotas, or tools to secure accounts like AWS GuardDuty and Amazon Inspector, infosec pros can work around platform limitations.

Chatterjee said the interviewees mostly mentioned AWS, but added that Google Cloud Platform abuse has been documented too. These companies, she said, are aware that abuse happens but they don't sufficiently monitor basic accounts to stop it.

The Register asked AWS and Google for comment. A Google spokesperson pointed to the company's [2]acceptable use policy for GCP. AWS did not respond but has a similar [3]policy .

Staying under the radar

The boffins identified several common attack scenarios in a companion paper, "Launching Stealth Attacks using Cloud"

[4]PDF

.

Wakey-wakey! A quarter of IT pros only get 3-4 hours' kip – and you won't believe what's being touted as the 'solution' [5]READ MORE

It outlines attack scenarios like using cloud platforms for phishing, DDoS, password cracking, rogue services, and other operations like running command-and-control servers. It also covers setting up an example attack server using Oracle VirtualBox and Kali Linux.

Both papers are scheduled to appear at the IEEE Computer Society Signature Conference on Computers, Software and Application ( [6]COMPSAC 2020 ) in July.

The researchers suggest some ways cloud providers might deal with abuse more effectively. One involves better customer identity verification through background checks. The availability of websites offering fake credit card numbers, the researchers say, makes it easy to create cloud accounts anonymously.

They also suggest better tracking of network usage and more intelligent VM monitoring to detect suspicious accounts. Cloud providers, they say, can enforce the use of firewalls, encourage software updates on VMs to protect against vulnerabilities, and create trusted software repositories to limit the availability of attack tools on their platforms.

Such measures, however, would impose costs on cloud providers and might alienate customers if the oversight is too heavy-handed.

Akbar Siami-Namin, associate professor of computer science at Texas Tech University and a co-author of the two papers, told The Reg there are both technical and business challenges cloud providers need to deal with.

"Security and particularly addition of security controls to infrastructure means additional costs," he said. "It also negatively impacts the 'usability' of the underlying systems. In the cloud platform, since it is a distributed environment, it is super hard to define a solid fortress in order to prevent adversaries from abusing it."

He also pointed to the business challenges entailed by adding friction to the customer acquisition process.

"Individuals are less likely to try something on the cloud, if the cloud is asking for so much private information such as credit card, name, address, etc," he said. "Therefore, the cloud providers offer some sort of basic computation power as 'free' with the hope that the potential customers (individuals) become regular customers for their cloud platforms (a long range investment)."

Those who would abuse cloud systems, he said, take advantage of this goodwill gesture.

"The cloud providers are aware of this issue," Siami-Namin said. However, from a technical point of view, it is hard to make the system bullet-proof and protected from attacks and abuse. As pointed out in our papers, perhaps they need a more mature, resilient, and monitoring tracking system empowered with AI and automated detection to identify these abuses." ®

Sponsored: [7]Security Features of Connect for Anthos



[1] https://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.07914.pdf

[2] https://cloud.google.com/terms/aup

[3] https://aws.amazon.com/aup/

[4] https://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.07908.pdf

[5] https://www.theregister.com/2020/04/28/uk_it_pros_sleep_patterns_report/

[6] https://ieeecompsac.computer.org/2020/

[7] https://go.theregister.com/tl/1956/-8474/security-features-of-connect-for-anthos?td=wptl1956

It is happening now

Flak

If white hats are using cloud services for attacks, we can be sure that the nasty ones are already doing this.

That should come as no surprise, given cloud platforms' very attractive features for this kind of activity: scale, immediacy, location independence, low cost, virtualisation and the associated anonymity to name a few.

Platform providers need to be vigilant in who they provide services to - but this is countered by the desired ease of use and onboarding needed to make those platforms attractive.

I am sure we haven't heard the last of this yet.

Re: It is happening now

Steve Foster

It certainly is.

The number of attempts to log in to my email servers via SMTP, 2ry SMTP, IMAP and POP3 are through the roof.

In the past, it would be the same IP trying over and over (though there's still plenty of that), but it's now also common to see an IP try once and then disappear. And lots of those IPs are part of cloud providers networks.

Not only that, but the spam is also coming from an increasing range of IP addresses.

I've had to further reduce the limit on failed login attempts, as well as begin firewall blocking of IP ranges wholesale.

Re: It is happening now

Chozo

Seriously.. you expect a true Blackhat to pay for cloud services? No, it's far cheaper to piggyback a Raspberry PI onto the motherboard of a dozen refurbished desktop PC's and return them to the wild. Stick in a half decent graphics card, label it "suitable for gaming" and they also tend to land in places with a nice unlimited fibre connection. Scanning the wifi card periodically we quickly learn when all cellphones have left the house for work then kick the pig till the fans squeal and we're making bacon on your budget.

Keep IT Simple, Stupid ....... for IT and AI Makes Life So Much Easier whenever Complicated

amanfromMars 1

"perhaps they need a more mature, resilient, and monitoring tracking system empowered with AI and automated detection to identify these abuses."

Or perhaps they need a more mature, resilient monitored mentoring system empowered with AI with automated detection which identifies abuses and misuses.

Thus to render the need for a retroactive and reactive [after the fact] human operations basically unnecessary.

Are cloud providers are aware of this issue?

"nine out of ten 'ethical' hackers are being a bit naughty..."

Mike 137

There's no need for the quotes around the word ethical. if your community ethics include being naughty, then it's OK within your community. The problem arises only when the ethical systems of different communities are in conflict.

However at least in the UK, such activities are potentially unlawful. They could therefore backfire badly supposing service providers and law enforcement really gave a hoot, but they don't really seem to so the habit gets reinforced until it becomes a norm.

"fake credit card numbers"

Pascal Monett

The fact that fake card numbers exist and can be used points to a lack of security on the part of banks. In Luxembourg, it is not enough to have a credit card for online transactions anymore. I have a USB-like token that, on the press of a button, gives me a 6-digit PIN code that I have to enter to validate my purchase.

If banks all over the world adopted that level of functionality, the fake card issue would disappear by itself.

Re: "fake credit card numbers"

iron

No it wouldn't. You'd just get a trade in security tokens to replace it.

Bollocks headline

iron

> Boffins find that over nine out of ten 'ethical' hackers...

> "We did not collect any demographic data, so we can not tell apart an ethical hacker/pen-tester or malicious hackers,"

If they did not ask any questions to distinguish the hat a hacker wears then they cannot make the statement in the headline.

Usage: fortune -P [] -a [xsz] [Q: [file]] [rKe9] -v6[+] dataspec ... inputdir