News: 1589918472

  ARM Give a man a fire and he's warm for a day, but set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life (Terry Pratchett, Jingo)

Beer rating app reveals homes and identities of spies and military bods, warns Bellingcat

(2020/05/19)


A beer and pub-rating app built off the back of Foursquare’s location-tracking API poses a risk to the security of military and intelligence personnel, according to legendary OSINT website Bellingcat.

Untappd 'has over eight million mostly European and North American users, and its features allow researchers to uncover sensitive information about said users at military and intelligence locations around the world,' wrote Bellingcat’s Foeke Postma in a [1]fascinating guide to using the app for tracking down people of interest.

Bellingcat is an open-source intelligence and investigative journalism website. Its most famous contribution to the world was identifying the Russian military personnel who shot down Malaysian Airlines flight MH17, something that saw [2]Russian hackers target it in revenge .

Untappd’s concept of operations is simple. You go to the pub and drink beer. During the beer-drinking process you take a picture of your beer with your smartphone and rate it. You can also rate the pub and leave comments. To do these things you need to register an account and provide some personal details – or log in with Facebook.

“Untappd users log hundreds, often thousands of time-stamped location data points. These locations are neatly sorted in over 900 categories, which can be as diverse and specific as 'botanic garden.' 'strip club,' 'gay bar,' 'west-Ukrainian restaurant,' and 'airport gate.' As the result of this, the app allows anyone to trace the movements of other users between sensitive locations,' wrote Bellingcat’s Postma.

All you need to do to deploy Untappd as an intelligence-gathering tool is use the app through its normal user interface. With a little knowledge of how the app works plus access to online map websites that list pub, bar and restaurant details, it’s scarily simple to find people who probably shouldn’t be easily findable.

So we put it to the test

Using Bellingcat’s techniques, The Register was easily able to identify someone who enjoyed a few pints over the years at hostelries close to, among other places: GCHQ Cheltenham; the Atomic Weapons Establishment base at Aldermaston; an Army base at South Cerney in Gloucestershire; and his regular pub crawls around his hometown, which we are not naming.

The person concerned used his own mugshot as his profile picture on the app. Although Untappd only displays users’ first names and initials, this particular one used his surname as part of his username, so the app displayed 'Joe B. (bloggs123)' on his profile. It was a trivial step from there to find him on Linkedin (with the job title 'analyst') and cross-match that against postal address records for his name in his hometown.

Looking at pubs and bars near the Royal Navy nuclear submarine base at Faslane, up in the lochs of western Scotland by Glasgow, proved equally fruitful. Putting himself into the mindset of a thirsty sailor looking for the nearest drinking establishment, your correspondent soon identified a cluster of bars within easy staggering distance of Helensburgh railway station, the first stop up the line from Faslane.

From there it was simple to look through recent Untappd check-ins at those bars and identify a US Navy nuclear submarine officer, complete with mugshot. His favourite establishments included on-base bars at a US naval station in Norfolk, Virginia, USA; bars next to naval bases in Spain; and 'Naval Base San Diego', included as an actual check-in location on a beer-rating app.

From a casual browse of the submariner’s friends list on the app, your correspondent found the profile of a woman who drank in the same bars at the same time as the man himself. Her profile picture on Untappd included children.

While the app itself is harmless, this ought to be a clear lesson for anyone in a sensitive job: do not use social media, and if you’re going to use social media anyway so you can have a normal life outside work, try not using it in a way where you pinpoint your precise location right next to your sensitive workplaces. Careless tagging, could, in some circumstances, cost lives. ®



[1] https://www.bellingcat.com/news/2020/05/18/military-and-intelligence-personnel-can-be-tracked-with-the-untappd-beer-app/

[2] https://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/09/29/russian_hackers_target_mh17_journos/

BebopWeBop

Loose lips cost lives

Pascal Monett

And that is now 70 years old . . .

Anonymous Coward

Loose lips sink ships.

Loose tweets destroy fleets. (Or so advised our local military installation.)

For any one in a sensitive job.

Mage

I'd say about social media:

1: Never post photos of self, family or friends. Use email or a private channel to share to family.

2: Never use your real name.

3: Never talk about where you live any more detailed than a county or city.

Unless you are famous and attention seeking, or selling on SM.

Best to avoid it altogether. There was a similar issue with an app that used fitbit or some other fitness tracker.

Why is Google allowed to buy fitbit?

Re: For any one in a sensitive job.

robidy

Happens all the time, didn't strava identify some secret bases...well they were secret...millitary intelligence as an oxymoron is alive and kicking.

Re: For any one in a sensitive job.

Anonymous Coward

Having an obscure name also helps as it turns out. You have to go 6 pages deep in Google before I turn up, linked to my github ironically (which is mostly empty).

Everything else is mostly looked down, save for the odd YouTube comment (though I have been quoted on one now over tea which amuses me no end) but it's always kept nice and short save for mild interaction and never for spite.

It always surprises me that so many people don't mind not using a pseudonym (though I know a few who intentional change name spellings for professional reasons which works for them).

Anon.

DavCrav

"Joe B. (bloggs123)"

Simpsons already did it.

"For privacy's sake let's call her Lisa S... No, that's too obvious, let's say L. Simpson."

"this particular one used his surname as part of his username"

Pascal Monett

It is truly astounding to realize that people who should be intelligent enough to know better still sell their lives to any app that tickles their funny bone.

I really would like to read a psychiatrist's study on this apparently innate need to sell one's personal life in order to give one's opinion on something.

Re: "this particular one used his surname as part of his username"

Glen 1

"YOU CAN'T ARREST ME!! I'M A SPY!!"

[1]The Tale of Michael Bettaney

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/7z3ad8/til_of_michael_bettaney_a_british_spy_who_while/

So Richard and I decided to try to catch [the small shark].
With a great deal of strategy and effort and shouting, we managed to
maneuver the shark, over the course of about a half-hour, to a sort of
corner of the lagoon, so that it had no way to escape other than to
flop up onto the land and evolve. Richard and I were inching toward
it, sort of crouched over, when all of a sudden it turned around and --
I can still remember the sensation I felt at that moment, primarily in
the armpit area -- headed right straight toward us.
Many people would have panicked at this point. But Richard and
I were not "many people." We were experienced waders, and we kept our
heads. We did exactly what the textbook says you should do when you're
unarmed and a shark that is nearly two feet long turns on you in water
up to your lower calves: We sprinted I would say 600 yards in the
opposite direction, using a sprinting style such that the bottoms of
our feet never once went below the surface of the water. We ran all
the way to the far shore, and if we had been in a Warner Brothers
cartoon we would have run right INTO the beach, and you would have seen
these two mounds of sand racing across the island until they bonked
into trees and coconuts fell onto their heads.
-- Dave Barry, "The Wonders of Sharks on TV"