News: 1589018593

  ARM Give a man a fire and he's warm for a day, but set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life (Terry Pratchett, Jingo)

I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Spacecraft with graphene sails powered by starlight and lasers

(2020/05/09)


Coin-sized pieces of graphene can be accelerated by firing low-powered lasers at them in micro-gravity conditions, say scientists. The technology could be a stepping stone to graphene solar sails, which could propel future spacecraft using starlight or a laser array.

The material was developed at Delft University of Technology in the Netherlands, and Scale Nanotech, a startup in Estonia. The project, backed by the European Space Agency, is experimenting with graphene to develop prototype light sails.

“Light sailing is the only existing in-space propulsion technology that could allow us to visit other star systems in a human lifespan,” the scientists stated in a paper, [1]published in Acta Astronautica. “In order to best harness radiation pressure, light sails need to be highly reflective, lightweight and mechanically robust.”

To make these sails, the team crafted an atomically thin 2D film punctured with tiny holes, and covered it with a layer of graphene. Next, they traveled to the [2]ZARM drop tower , a laboratory at the University of Bremen, Germany, that uses a 146-metre steel tube to simulate micro-gravity conditions to test their graphene coins. When the material was dropped inside and floating effectively weightlessly, it was accelerated 1 m/s 2 by zapping it with a 1W laser. The photons in the laser light exerted a pressure on the material causing it to move faster and faster.

[3]

A close up of a graphene light-sail prototype ... Its surface is punctured with holes to reduce its overall mass.

Click to enlarge. Image Credit: Santiago Jose Cartamil-Bueno

In space, light sails could be powered by sunlight rather than lasers: the Sun’s rays, for instance, would provide a way for probes to travel without the need to carry heavy fuel, such as liquid propellant, and engines. However, to sail at decent speeds, the material needs to be expansive in order to catch enough of the Sun’s photons. And as the sails move further from the Sun, they'll slow down. There is hope, though: scientists believe it may be possible to nudge the sails along with an array of lasers. The array could be on Earth, a base on the Moon or Mars, or on an orbiting platform, we reckon.

Santiago Cartamil-Bueno, coauthor of the paper and the leader of the GrapheneSail team at Scale Nanotech, believes "graphene is part of the solution" to developing practical light sails.

Boffins manage to keep graphene qubits 'quantum coherent' for all of 55... nanoseconds [4]READ MORE

"We demonstrate a novel sail design that reduces the overall sail mass by using perforated films," Cartamil-Bueno said. "By covering the holes with graphene, the full area of the sail is again available for optical performance at minimal mass cost. The fabrication is relatively simple and could be easily scaled up to squared kilometres, although the in-space deployment of such a giant sail will be a serious challenge."

Just how big the sail would have to be depends on how fast it needs to reach its target, Cartamil-Bueno told The Register this week: “The US [5]Breakthrough Starshot envisions a sail of about 14m 2 at four grams traveling at 15 per cent of the speed of light to reach Alpha Centauri in 30 years with the help of 8.5GW lasers. Graphene sails of such a size enable these types of extreme sails.”

The biggest challenge is the sheer amount of laser power needed, he said. Not only does it require the synchronization of thousands or millions of lasers, it may pose a political dilemma, too. “Such a laser system could be used as a weapon, and not many nations will trust it being there,” he said.

The most successful light sail experiment to date is the Interplanetary Kite-craft Accelerated by Radiation of the Sun, or [6]IKAROS for short, an experimental spacecraft launched by Japan's space agency in 2010. The probe flew past Venus thanks to its 340kg square-shaped light sail, measuring 14 x 14 metres, made out of polyimide.

The Planetary Society also launched its LightSail 2 model into orbit around Earth last year, and [7]released a few images of it travelling in space. ®

Sponsored: [8]Forrester Build a Digital Experience Portfolio



[1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0094576520301582?via%3Dihub

[2] https://www.esa.int/Education/Drop_Your_Thesis/The_ZARM_drop_tower_in_Bremen

[3] https://regmedia.co.uk/2020/05/07/graphene_lightsail.jpg

[4] https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/01/02/boffins_have_made_qubits_from_graphene_for_the_first_time/

[5] https://breakthroughinitiatives.org/initiative/3

[6] https://global.jaxa.jp/countdown/f17/overview/ikaros_e.html

[7] https://www.planetary.org/blogs/ten-new-lightsail-2-pics.html

[8] https://go.theregister.co.uk/tl/1936/-8554/forrester-build-a-digital-experience-portfolio?td=wptl1936

Calling Isaac Newton...

Pen-y-gors

And as the sails move further from the Sun, they'll slow down.

Well, yes, but, no but... I suppose that interstellar drag will have a small effect, but check Sir Isaac's First Law of Motion.

perhaps you mean 'the rate of acceleration will decrease'

Re: Calling Isaac Newton...

Raymond Berenger

Perhaps it means that the force of gravity from the Sun will exceed the force on the sails and they will indeed slow down.

I find this kind of speculative engineering interesting but, in practical terms, extremely unconvincing. It seems to imply a level of development of civilisation at which we might have much better ways of sending long distance probes - or perhaps have even decided not to bother.

Certainly I can't think of a single government, even somewhere like Malta, that I'd trust with an 8GW orbiting laser.

Re: Calling Isaac Newton...

Tom 7

If they had one Malta would have very good press quite quickly though!

Re: Calling Isaac Newton...

steelpillow

"Perhaps it means that the force of gravity from the Sun will exceed the force on the sails"

Nope. Gravity obeys an inverse square law. Lasers are, to a first approximation, constant with distance.

Re: Calling Isaac Newton...

Pier Reviewer

The problem is that the closer you get to another star the more pressure it exerts on your sail in the wrong direction. That’s why you need the laser. However you need to focus your laser on a 14m2 area at a distance of ~4 LY. Not exactly a trivial design requirement.

Then there’s the second issue - you arrive in the Alpha Centauri system at ~15% c. You need some way to slow down or you’ll just barrel straight through. If you’re spending that much time, money and effort getting to another star system you probably want to get some data back. You’ll have trouble getting through the submission phase if you’re basically proposing throwing billions of at a star using a giant **** off laser.

That’s the biggest issue with any kind of fast travel. You need to slow down without turning your payload to jam/dust. Consider the difference between going from 70mph to 0mph in a controlled fashion vs stopping fairly instantaneously through the help of a bridge support.

Re: Calling Isaac Newton...

Mage

Yes, it's Crazy Eddie stuff. But on the gripping hand, lots of Crazy Eddie stuff doesn't work.

Re: Calling Isaac Newton...

druck

@Pier Reviewer your first question answers your second. You use your own star to accelerate, and the destination star to decelerate. You'll need the ability to vary the area of the sail in order to get the correct numbers at each phase of travel.

Re: Slowing down

Flocke Kroes

About half way to the destination detach the out half of the sail (4x the area of the inner half) and use it as a mirror. Use magic to keep the outer part pointing in the right direction and the inner part will slow down.

Richard Tobin

'Such a laser system could be used as a weapon'

Cf the Kzinti lesson https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/WeaponizedExhaust

Chris G

Have an upvote and a beer.

On reading the headline, Larry Niven came to mind immediately.

1m/s**2

Tom 7

So in a day that would be a pathetic 54 miles a second or close on 200,000mph. Not to be sneezed at without a mask.

steelpillow

My next SF novella is now going to have the main protagonist, a solar-powered AI space station, buying laser boost from a handy laser "filling station" whenever it is in a hurry. What to call the station brand? It won't be BP.

Shame that any patent will have expired by the time it actually happens. You read it here first!

"The probe flew past Venus thanks to its 340kg square-shaped light sail"

Anonymous Coward

I hate to be pedantic, actually no I love it, but from the very page you linked to:

"LightSail-1 is an ultra-light spacecraft with a mass of less than 5 kilograms"

Your mind understands what you have been taught; your heart, what is true.