News: 1587980527

  ARM Give a man a fire and he's warm for a day, but set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life (Terry Pratchett, Jingo)

Cosmo Communicator: Phone-laptop hybrid is neat, if niche, tilt at portable productivity

(2020/04/27)


Hands on It must be stressed right off the bat that a "phone" like Planet Computers' Cosmo Communicator is an incredibly niche device.

It's modelled after the old Psion PDAs of yore, and a younger audience, perhaps unfamiliar with tech of the 1990s, might look at it as a weird phone-laptop hybrid that has been shrunk in the washer.

The thing is, both of those things are true: The Cosmo is a nostalgic throwback, but it's also an attempt to reconsider what portable productivity looks like. And the end result is a machine that's both intriguing and polarising, and guaranteed to win fans and detractors in equal measure.

The [1]Cosmo is the latest in a line of Psion Series 5-inspired tools. The first was the [2]Gemini PDA , which I got my mucky paws on last year. Like its predecessor, the Cosmo was first funded via a successful Indiegogo campaign, although now can be found on tech stores like [3]Clove . Early next year, Planet Computers will release the [4]Astro Slide , which packs 5G and a more conventional slider form factor.

Ultimately, there aren't that many surprises with the Cosmo as the diminutive laptop-style device builds on the same strengths of its predecessor. The build quality remains excellent, with a hinge that vigorously snaps into place when the device opens. The keyboard is responsive and consistent, with excellent key travel and a layout that maximises the limited amount of real estate. However, it's nonetheless a bit pokey, and even with repeated use, it's hard to build the muscle memory to permit touch typing.

[5]

If you're hoping for a machine that will allow you to type like you would on a laptop, this ain't it. However, its form factor arguably lends itself to situations where a traditional laptop isn't well suited, like when plonked in a middle seat on a Ryanair 737 (remember those?). And it is nice to have a machine with a proper keyboard that comfortably fits into the pocket of one's Levi's.

At the top of the device, there's a small OLED display to show notifications, as well as a camera and a fingerprint reader that also doubles as a toggle for the secondary screen.

[6]

Crack it open, and you're in laptop mode. The display here isn't the brightest or richest we've ever seen, particularly when contrasted against the latest-and-greatest flagships. It struggles in bright, sunny conditions. Indoors, however, it's perfectly fine. And realistically, this is a machine intended for those spurts of productivity that happen when you aren't chained to your desk.

The Cosmo provided to The Register runs Android 9 Pie, and comes with a boatload of apps designed to take advantage of the device's quirky form factor, including an OS X-style app launcher. There are also a few Psion-inspired productivity apps bundled, including a calendar called Agenda. The Cosmo can also run Linux, although we didn't test that.

Under the hood is a Mediatek P70 platform, paired with 6GB of RAM and 128GB of internal storage. Although these are fairly middle-of-the-road specs, I didn't find any reason to grumble, with no perceptible lag when multitasking and performing otherwise computationally taxing tasks.

Battery life, however, is another matter. Despite the unit coming with a whopping 4,200mAh cell, I still found myself running for the wall outlet several times during the same day. And that will obviously dent its appeal to the (now-grounded) road-warrior elite. At least it's replaceable and user-serviceable, which isn't always guaranteed.

Connectivity wise, there's a dual-SIM slot, as well as dual USB-C ports. One is used for charging, while another can connect peripherals, including a secondary monitor. There's also a 3.5mm headphone jack.

The 5MP selfie camera is ideal for video conferencing, although less conducive for Instagram duckface, while the 24MP sensor on the rear didn't rock our socks.

So, here's the interesting thing about the Cosmo: it's not a particularly good smartphone or laptop. But as a third-category device serving as a bridge between the two, it's genuinely compelling and a testament to the viability of Android as a platform for getting stuff done.

There's a huge part of me that hopes Planet Computers takes what it has learned from the Cosmo and turns it to developing a proper 11-inch laptop. The industrial design of the Cosmo is genuinely good, feeling robust in all the right parts. The keyboard is excellent, despite the pokiness. And Planet Computers has managed to make Android work for this unfailingly niche category of product.

This isn't a device I would recommend to everyone. But for those with bulging air-mile balances, it's worthy of consideration. If you're tempted, the Cosmo is available online for £800, which doesn't seem like pocket change to us. ®

Sponsored: [7]How To Accelerate Brilliant Digital Experiences With Low-Code



[1] https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/10/04/planet_launches_cosmo_communicator_phone_with_real_keyboard_android_or_linux/

[2] https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/04/11/life_with_gemini/

[3] https://www.clove.co.uk/search?type=product&q=planet+computers

[4] https://www.theregister.co.uk/2020/03/30/planet_computers_astro_slide/

[5] https://regmedia.co.uk/2020/04/24/dscf1002.jpg

[6] https://regmedia.co.uk/2020/04/24/dscf0522.jpg

[7] https://go.theregister.co.uk/tl/1936/-8552/how-to-accelerate-brilliant-digital-experiences-with-low-code?td=wptl1936

Deal breaker

Dr_N

"Despite the unit coming with a whopping 4,200mAh cell, I still found myself running for the wall outlet several times during the same day."

Game Over for me.

I threw some money at this....

theOtherJT

...when it was still fund raising, and thus got one considerably cheaper. For the money I paid at the time I'm very happy, but I really couldn't in good conscience recommend one to someone at the £700 plus they're asking for it now.

I use mine a lot with a USB->serial dongle for fixing switches in out of the way cabinets, and it's really, really good at that. It's also pretty great at being an SSH terminal for when I'm in the pub and someone has sent me an "Urgent" support request that really just requires me to SSH to something and restart a service/the whole box. But there are a lot of things it's not very good at. Android really struggles with running in landscape - a ton of apps, including just the chrome browser - really aren't expecting you to do that and often don't display their content in a sensible way.

Running Linux on it is also... an experience. One best reserved for people who like doing Linux development, because almost _nothing_ works properly at the moment. If it goes into power saving? You're not getting it back. Reboot. If you close the lid, nothing happens. The external screen doesn't seem to work at all in Linux (and works somewhat patchily in Android for that matter - I've been through a good 20 rounds of update firmware -> reboot -> repeat to get that to update properly.

If you have a very specific need for a device like this - which I do - then there isn't really anything to match it, but it suffers the same problem that nearly all low-volume small developer community projects do: It's made almost entirely of rough edges.

Re: I threw some money at this....

Dr AntiSol, astrophysicist

Thanks for this, I found it informative. I have been looking into the cosmo and waiting for Linux to become available for it (I didn't know they released it recently, a good step in the right direction). But I want something usable - It sounds like I should wait a little longer for it to stabilise and get the bugs ironed out.

The article's comments on battery life are a bit of a concern, too. Could you give some more detail as to your experience with battery life / usage? Thanks! :)

Re: I threw some money at this....

theOtherJT

The battery life under android isn't _terrible_ for a device of this size... it's not good tho. I find that if I don't charge it nightly it'll probably be dead the next time I want to use it. The battery life under linux is utterly woeful. It doesn't appear to do any power management (or that that it might do you need to turn off because of the aforementioned locking and refusing to unlock problem) so you'll struggle to get more than 3 or 4 hours out of it booted into debian.

Why are you going with Psion comparisons?

corestore

To me at least, the obvious resemblance is to a Nokia Communicator.

Re: Why are you going with Psion comparisons?

A Non e-mouse

I've used both a Nokia Communicator (Several flavors) and Psion devices (several flavors) It's definitely more like a Psion than a Communicator.

Chris G

My Ulefone Armor two has 6Gb RAM and 64Gb ROM plus a 128Gb card, 4700mAH of battery, is water and dust proof and easily lasts a day of heavy use.

Oh and the selfie camera is 8mp.

I loved the Psion but a modern take on it would need to be significantly better to appeal.

A Non e-mouse

Mmmm, not seeing a physical keyboard on those devices....?

Clove

Benson's Cycle

As a satisfied long term customer (with no other business connection) I'd just mention that Clove, mentioned in the article, is a good independent seller and worth a look. I wouldn't buy a Cosmo - it doesn't suit my use case these days at all - but being able to get it from them does add a little credibility.

So near, but

Vaughtex

After having a Psion back in the day, I'd kept an eye on Planet when they announced the Gemini, but didn't jump in shall we say and finally bought a Gemini off eBay last year to see what I'd been missing. Both the hands on and some of the comments are spot on, the Gemini and the Communicator are both well built though niche products, but both are let down somewhat by software support from Planet.

Judging by the tales of woe from the various online groups, it seems that some of the functions that didn't work on the Gemini, external display support in Linux for one, still has problems if it works at all, on the Cosmo, with most fingers pointing at adoption/implementation of the Meditek processor. What also seems to have happened is software development on the older device tailing off when the newer device arrived. I fully expect that will reoccur when the Astro Slide appears.

It's a pity as they're a nice device, but as with other companies, Planet appear to be funding development of a new product before and at the expense of getting the old one to work as advertised. There again, Microsoft managed that for years....

Bibbit

The article mentions wanting a good 11” laptop. but I got myself an Asus EEEPC 901 for £25 at an online auction. 10” screen, great keyboard. I bunged minimal Xubuntu core on it and it is a nice little machine for travel stuff.

I saw what you did and I know who you are.