Did Tim Cook Post AI Slop in His Christmas Message Promoting 'Pluribus'? (daringfireball.net)
(Monday December 29, 2025 @11:41AM (EditorDavid)
from the from-many-one dept.)
Artist Keith Thomson is a [1]modern (and whimsical) Edward Hopper . And Apple TV [2]says he created the "festive artwork" [3]shared on X by Apple CEO Tim Cook on Christmas Eve, "made on MacBook Pro."
Its intentionally-off picture of milk and cookies was meant to tease the season finale of Pluribus . ("Merry Christmas Eve, Carol..." Cook had posted.)
But others were convinced that the weird image was AI-generated.
[4]Tech blogger John Gruber was blunt . "Tim Cook posts AI Slop in Christmas message on Twitter/X, ostensibly to promote 'Pluribus'."
> As for sloppy details, the carton is labeled both "Whole Milk" and "Lowfat Milk", and the "Cow Fun Puzzle" maze is just goofily wrong. (I can't recall ever seeing a puzzle of any kind on a milk carton, because they're waxy and hard to write on. It's like a conflation of milk cartons and cereal boxes.)
Tech author Ben Kamens — who just days earlier had [5]blogged about generating mazes with AI — said the image showed the " [6]specific quirks " of generative AI mazes (including the way the maze couldn't be solved, expect by going around the maze altogether). Former Google Ventures partner [7]M.G. Siegler even wondered if AI use intentionally echoed the [8]themes of Pluribus — e.g., the creepiness of a collective intelligence — since otherwise "this seems far too obvious to be a mistake/blunder on Apple's part." ( [9]Someone on Reddit pointed out that in Pluribus 's dystopian world, [10]milk plays a key role — and the open spout of the "natural" milk's carton does touch a suspiciously-shining light on the Christmas tree...)
Slashdot [11]contacted artist Keith Thomson to try to ascertain what happened ...
[1] https://www.keiththomsonart.com/
[2] https://x.com/appletv/status/2003927243245203539
[3] https://x.com/tim_cook/status/2003873311504130173
[4] https://daringfireball.net/linked/2025/12/27/slopibus
[5] https://kamens.com/blog/generating-custom-mazes-with-ai
[6] https://x.com/kamens/status/2004441805962764779
[7] https://spyglass.org/apples-pluribus-ai/
[8] https://spyglass.org/pluribus-as-ai-allegory/
[9] https://www.reddit.com/r/facepalm/comments/1pv48uw/comment/nvtt3o2/
[10] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Got_Milk_(Pluribus)
[11] https://apple.slashdot.org/story/25/12/28/2048225/did-tim-cook-post-ai-slop-in-his-christmas-message-promoting-pluribus#keith_thomson_says
Its intentionally-off picture of milk and cookies was meant to tease the season finale of Pluribus . ("Merry Christmas Eve, Carol..." Cook had posted.)
But others were convinced that the weird image was AI-generated.
[4]Tech blogger John Gruber was blunt . "Tim Cook posts AI Slop in Christmas message on Twitter/X, ostensibly to promote 'Pluribus'."
> As for sloppy details, the carton is labeled both "Whole Milk" and "Lowfat Milk", and the "Cow Fun Puzzle" maze is just goofily wrong. (I can't recall ever seeing a puzzle of any kind on a milk carton, because they're waxy and hard to write on. It's like a conflation of milk cartons and cereal boxes.)
Tech author Ben Kamens — who just days earlier had [5]blogged about generating mazes with AI — said the image showed the " [6]specific quirks " of generative AI mazes (including the way the maze couldn't be solved, expect by going around the maze altogether). Former Google Ventures partner [7]M.G. Siegler even wondered if AI use intentionally echoed the [8]themes of Pluribus — e.g., the creepiness of a collective intelligence — since otherwise "this seems far too obvious to be a mistake/blunder on Apple's part." ( [9]Someone on Reddit pointed out that in Pluribus 's dystopian world, [10]milk plays a key role — and the open spout of the "natural" milk's carton does touch a suspiciously-shining light on the Christmas tree...)
Slashdot [11]contacted artist Keith Thomson to try to ascertain what happened ...
[1] https://www.keiththomsonart.com/
[2] https://x.com/appletv/status/2003927243245203539
[3] https://x.com/tim_cook/status/2003873311504130173
[4] https://daringfireball.net/linked/2025/12/27/slopibus
[5] https://kamens.com/blog/generating-custom-mazes-with-ai
[6] https://x.com/kamens/status/2004441805962764779
[7] https://spyglass.org/apples-pluribus-ai/
[8] https://spyglass.org/pluribus-as-ai-allegory/
[9] https://www.reddit.com/r/facepalm/comments/1pv48uw/comment/nvtt3o2/
[10] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Got_Milk_(Pluribus)
[11] https://apple.slashdot.org/story/25/12/28/2048225/did-tim-cook-post-ai-slop-in-his-christmas-message-promoting-pluribus#keith_thomson_says