Instead of Fighting AI, Some Teachers Work It Into Their Lessons (msn.com)
- Reference: 0185481202
- News link: https://news.slashdot.org/story/26/09/07/0021232/instead-of-fighting-ai-some-teachers-work-it-into-their-lessons
- Source link: https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/general/these-teachers-are-moving-from-ai-policing-to-ai-acceptance/ar-AA2bEPsP
But was there a better way?
> She is one of a dozen educators around the country who told The Post that they're experimenting with a different approach to student use of generative artificial intelligence this school year. Teachers and professors are throwing out old assignments, installing new policies and protocols, and incorporating AI built for the classroom, rather than feeling forced to choose between returning to pencil and paper or acting like the AI police.
>
> Her new lesson plan even incorporates generative AI in a controlled way to let her evaluate students' critical thinking skills. She created chatbots using BoodleBox, the university's AI vendor, that allow instructors to see both sides of the conversation. For an assignment testing students' ability to make evidence-based arguments, they participate in a simulated school board meeting about banning books. It involves debating chatbots designed by Zeleny with names like the Confrontational Parent. Writing students usually turn in business proposals and research papers. This semester, instructors are starting to ask instead for transcripts of conversations a student had with a chatbot, a handwritten outline of their composition, and a video reflection of how they felt about the work. "In a lot of ways, we have made these assignments harder, but writing should have always had more detailed checkpoints along the way," she said.
[1] https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/general/these-teachers-are-moving-from-ai-policing-to-ai-acceptance/ar-AA2bEPsP
Cut off the problem before it starts (Score:1)
There is an epidemic of kids telling teachers that something must be right because AI said it. Realistically, this is the only way to cut that problem off early. ...I deal with it all the time with adults at work in their 50s...
If you can't beat them, join them (Score:2)
That's the crux of the article. The lame attempts at AI-integrated assessments are ineffectual, and that why we read "that's what we're trying now" rather than "we've tried this and *works* and *they learn*". It's just AI, hopes and prayers. Of course, no mention of how AI use negatively affects learning, as shown by multiple studies.
adverse training for students (Score:2)
Flood them with options and force them to pick the right one. It might work. Sure sucks for those students if the new teaching policies don't work.