Nvidia, Microsoft, Meta Warn Against 'Premature Restrictions' of Open-Weight Models
- Reference: 0184657022
- News link: https://meta.slashdot.org/story/26/07/24/1911233/nvidia-microsoft-meta-warn-against-premature-restrictions-of-open-weight-models
- Source link:
> They wrote that open-weight models strengthen competition and ensure that the benefits of the technology are "broadly shared rather than concentrated in a few hands." "Relying solely on closed models is not inherently safe: they can be breached, misused, or fail in ways that outsiders cannot detect," the letter said. "And concentrating advanced AI capabilities behind a small number of closed models compounds that risk."
>
> Elon Musk, who runs an AI business under his rocket company SpaceX, also applified the letter on social media, writing that it has his "full support" in [3]a post on X. SpaceX did not officially sign the letter. Greg Brockman, OpenAI's president, said Thursday that the company believes in broad access, and that he has not been involved in any conversations with the Trump administration about potentially banning Chinese open-weight models in the U.S.
>
> "I think that, that fundamentally, AI and AI usage is something that is actually very important to democratize," Brockman told reporters during a briefing in New York City. "And so, for me, at a sort of deep level, I think that having more models, more usage, that is a good thing." OpenAI CEO Sam Altman addressed the letter in [4]a post on X on Friday, writing that he wants the U.S. to win with both open-weight and proprietary models, and that he is "glad to see this."
>
> [...] In the letter on Friday, the U.S. tech companies said that concerns about unlawful distillation should be addressed through "targeted legal and commercial frameworks" instead of with "sweeping restrictions on techniques that play an important role in AI innovation." "Our AI leadership will be judged not by one frontier AI model, but by whether the United States builds a strong, open ecosystem that diffuses into every sector," the letter said. "This is essential for creating opportunities for innovation and prosperity across the country."
The letter follows a [5]separate appeal signed by nearly 200 Silicon Valley companies, including Proton and Y Combinator, warning that restricting U.S. access to Chinese open-weight AI models could cripple the next generation of American startups. "American leadership requires two things: world-leading American open-weight models and continued access for U.S. builders to open models already available worldwide," the startup founders wrote. Instead of broad prohibitions, they argue the government should adopt targeted safeguards.
Of course, these signees "have an obvious economic stake in seeing open AI models flourish," notes [6]TechCrunch . "Companies like Nvidia, Microsoft Azure, and other infrastructure providers have a vested interest in pushing for commoditized models: If models are interchangeable, people will buy more GPUs, rent more cloud capacity, and build more applications."
[1] https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/corporate-responsibility/topics/open-weight/
[2] https://www.cnbc.com/2026/07/24/nvidia-microsoft-meta-open-weight-ai-models.html
[3] https://x.com/elonmusk/status/2080672505660834163?s=20
[4] https://x.com/sama/status/2080683363174945065
[5] https://slashdot.org/story/26/07/23/0623233/startup-founders-urge-trump-not-to-shut-off-chinese-open-weight-ai
[6] https://techcrunch.com/2026/07/24/as-us-weighs-response-to-chinese-ai-industry-urges-against-broad-open-weight-restrictions/
Leapfrog (Score:3)
> ...limits [on access to foreign models] could "stifle competition or drive innovation overseas."
Translation: " They copied from us, and then released an improved version. If you block us from copying from them how will we build our more-improved version to leapfrog them?!? "
Everyone is copying everyone and each release is an improvement on the competing models. Restrictions will only slow down progress.
The government putting its thumb on the scale will not help to make better tools.
Restricting access to the masses (Score:2)
is by design and what the current regime wants.
We are being split into a 3 class society in the United States. That's right, no longer classless. More like the Roman "plebiscites" and the "patricians", coupled with the "citizens" and "probationers" in David Brin's sci-fi uplift universe
Patricians to plebs: "Rules are for thee and not for me.
Plebs to Probationers: No. you can't vote, and no, you can't reproduce, and we track everywhere you go and prohibit access to designated areas by a surgically implanted
Remember DEC? Silicon Graphics? Sun Microsystems? (Score:2)
Starting with the Intel 386 it became possible to run a proper operating system on consumer hardware. I can still recall the excitement with that first Redhat 3.03 book and CD I received, sitting in front of a 16MHz i386sx, craving change. I had owned a Vax 11/730, an LMI Lambda, an SGI 210GTXB, but they were just stupid expensive to run and it took a couple friends to move them.
Anthropic and OpenAI are in the same position the workstation vendors were thirty years ago. What they do is amazing, extremely de
"applified?" (Score:2)
> Elon Musk, who runs an AI business under his rocket company SpaceX, also applified the letter on social media
I think the Slashdot editors just unintentionally created a neologism.
So ... "applify" might mean "to draw attention to something through an app, or social media running on it."
Seems useful?
Re: (Score:2)
Just checked, it's in TFA also. So maybe the credit goes there.
Trump's just fishing for bribes again (Score:2)
It's pretty obvious what he's doing. It's just a question of how much they will have to pay to get what they want from him.
If you wanted the government to be run like a business congratulations. This is how businesses are run. Pay for play.
If you have a GPU and training data (Score:3)
You can make an open weight model. You can't put the AI cat back in the bag.
Re: (Score:2)
> You can't put the AI cat back in the bag.
You could send someone back in time to stop the robot that the AI sent back in time from killing the chick who is going to be the mother of the guy who puts the AI cat back in the bag.
Re: (Score:2)
you are dramatically underestimating the cost & processing needed to produce an model with actually useful weights.
Re: (Score:2)
This. There's a reason the big players are spending so much on data-centers and computational facilities.