160 miles north of New York City, a man was convicted of manslaughter "with the help of license plate reader technology," reports [1]a local news station . In the small town of Troy (population: 51,000), the mayor described the cameras as "a critical tool" in that investigation. But locals and city officials "have raised concerns about who can access the data collected locally, along with data security, privacy invasions and use by federal authorities, including U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, [2]reports WNYT :

> When Troy's contract came up for renewal, Mayor Carmella Mantello wanted to keep paying Flock and the council paused payments. The mayor then issued a public safety emergency declaration to keep the license plate readers active. The council has filed a lawsuit to overturn that..."If this illegal emergency order is left unchallenged, we give this mayor and any future mayor regardless of their political party or ideology, unchecked authority to issue an emergency declaration whenever they disagree with the council on any issue," [said Troy council president Sue Steele].

"The technology that's in place today is not the technology of six years ago," council president Steele [3]told another local news station . "We have AI, we have rapidly changing and advancing technology. So that begs the need for regulations to protect certain data." The [4]American Civil Liberties Union warns that Flock will use AI to let law enforcement search its trove of videos.

> But "Listen, if it was infringing on people's rights, people's liberties, we'd be the first to get rid of it. We have safeguards in place," [mayor] Mantello responded. Mantello noted that data captured by Troy's Flock cameras is only being shared with other local municipalities.

>

> Steele said the data had been shared nationally until she and other elected officials raised concerns. "As far as sharing with local law enforcement, that's necessary in the normal course of investigations. The concern is what Flock does with this data: sharing it with ICE, for instance, and other nefarious outlets," Steele said.

As the debate continues over the small city's 26 Flock cameras, a [5]columnist in Albany wrote that "it's a good thing. We should be asking questions about the growing surveillance state. We should be debating whether this is the future we want."

> As [6]the American Civil Liberties Union noted , [Flock] has quietly built a broad mass-surveillance infrastructure, with cameras installed in 5,000 communities around the country, and is continually expanding how that network is used. Did we ask for that? Did we vote for it? Not really. The cameras have been installed in municipality after municipality, mostly with little discussion or controversy, which makes us like the proverbial frogs who didn't notice the water getting warmer until it was boiling. Suddenly, surveillance cameras are everywhere; we're always being watched...

>

> [T]he City Council's Democratic majority is [7]considering legislation that, among other steps, would require that data collected by the cameras be generally deleted after 48 hours and that the city be more transparent about how the cameras are used.

The controversy and pushback [8]continues to draw local coverage . The mayor complains the proposed rules restricts the cameras "almost exclusively to cases involving individuals with outstanding felony arrest warrants or situations where officers can determine in advance that an incident will result in a felony charge... This is beyond reckless."

But the Albany columnist still argues many of America's Flock cameras [9]are unnecessary and are "being installed just because... It's worth considering where this might lead and whether the future we're installing is the future we want."



[1] https://cbs6albany.com/news/local/troy-conviction-lawsuit-and-elected-officials-on-flock-cameras

[2] https://wnyt.com/top-stories/dispute-between-city-council-mayor-over-flock-cameras-in-troy/

[3] https://cbs6albany.com/news/local/troy-conviction-lawsuit-and-elected-officials-on-flock-cameras

[4] https://www.aclu.org/news/privacy-technology/flock-roundup

[5] https://www.timesunion.com/churchill/article/churchill-troy-get-flock-out-22252986.php

[6] https://www.aclu.org/news/privacy-technology/flock-roundup

[7] https://www.troyny.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/ArchivedAgenda/_05072026-1527?packet=true

[8] https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/capital-region/news/2026/05/04/troy-council-proposes-law-to-regulate-license-plate-camera-readers-

[9] https://www.timesunion.com/churchill/article/churchill-troy-get-flock-out-22252986.php