Was the Airbus A320 Recall Caused By Cosmic Rays? (bbc.com)
- Reference: 0180328277
- News link: https://tech.slashdot.org/story/25/12/08/0625216/was-the-airbus-a320-recall-caused-by-cosmic-rays
- Source link: https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20251201-how-cosmic-rays-grounded-thousands-of-aircraft
The BBC believes radiation from space "could become a growing problem as ever more microchips run our lives."
> What Airbus says occurred on that JetBlue flight from Cancun to New Jersey was a phenomenon called a single-event upset, or bit flip. As the BBC has previously reported, these computer errors occur when high-speed subatomic particles from outer space, such as protons, [1]smash into atoms in our planet's atmosphere . This can cause a cascade of particles to rain down through our atmosphere, like throwing marbles across a table. In rare cases, those fast-moving neutrons can strike computer electronics and disrupt tiny bits of data stored in the computer's memory, switching that bit — often represented as a 0 or 1 — from one state to another. "That can cause your electronics to behave in ways you weren't expecting," says Matthew Owens, professor of space physics at the University of Reading in the UK. Satellites are particularly affected by this phenomenon, he says. "For space hardware we see this quite frequently."
>
> This is because the neutron flux — a measure of neutron radiation — rises the higher up in the atmosphere you go, increasing the chance of a strike hitting sensitive parts of the computer equipment on board. Aircraft are more vulnerable to this problem than computer equipment on the ground, although bit flips do occur at ground level, too. The increasing reliance of computers in fly-by-wire systems in aircraft, which use electronics rather than mechanical systems to control the plane in the air, also mean the risk posed by bit flips when they do occur is higher... Airbus told the BBC that it tested multiple scenarios when attempting to determine what happened to the 30 October 2025 JetBlue flight. In this case also, the company ruled out various possibilities except that of a bit flip. It is hard to attribute the incident to this for sure, however, because careering neutrons leave no trace of their activity behind, says Owens...
>
> [Airbus's software update] works by inducing "rapid refreshing of the corrupted parameter so it has no time to have effect on the flight controls", Airbus says. This is, in essence, a way of continually sanitising computer data on these aircraft to try and ensure that any errors don't end up actually impacting a flight... As computer chips have become smaller, they have also become more vulnerable to bit flips because the energy required to corrupt tiny packets of data has got lower over time. Plus, more and more microchips are being loaded into products and vehicles, potentially increasing the chance that a bit flip could cause havoc. If nothing else, the JetBlue incident will focus minds across many industries on the risk posed to our modern, microchip-dependent lives from cosmic radiation that originates far beyond our planet.
[2]Airbus said their analysis revealed "intense solar radiation" could corrupt data "critical to the functioning of flight control." But that explanation "has left some space weather scientists scratching their heads," adds the BBC.
[3] Space.com explains :
> Solar radiation levels on Oct. 30 were unremarkable and nowhere near levels that could affect aircraft electronics, Clive Dyer, a space weather and radiation expert at University of Surrey in the U.K., told Space.com. Instead, Dyer, who has studied effects of solar radiation on aircraft electronics for decades, thinks the onboard computer of the affected jet could have been struck by a cosmic ray, a stream of high-energy particles from a distant star explosion that may have travelled millions of years before reaching Earth. "[Cosmic rays] can interact with modern microelectronics and change the state of a circuit," Dyer said. "They can cause a simple bit flip, like a 0 to 1 or 1 to 0. They can mess up information and make things go wrong. But they can cause hardware failures too, when they induce a current in an electronic device and burn it out."
[1] https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20221011-how-space-weather-causes-computer-errors
[2] https://www.airbus.com/sites/g/files/jlcbta136/files/2025-11/airbus_update_on_a320_family_precautionary_fleet_action.pdf
[3] https://www.space.com/technology/aerospace/cosmic-ray-forces-airliner-emergency-landing
Overthinking it... (Score:1)
So the likelihood of a memory/wordsize handling bug that might lead to heap overrides is less likely than cosmic radiation bitflip? Amazing! These companies must really employ the most professional and honest engineers on the planet. Makes you think if you only want to fly Airbus from now on. ...I'd say their cosmic radiation comment is more concerning than the recall itself.
A funny scary thing (Score:3)
For decades, people have dismissed bit flips caused by cosmic rays, but here's what I've been dealing with: I have four 16 GB sticks of DDR4 RAM running at stock without overclocking or anything. At least once a week, the Linux kernel displays this message:
> mce: [Hardware Error]: Machine check events logged
> mce: [Hardware Error]: CPU 1: Machine Check: 0 Bank 19: 9460eb40d5040348
> mce: [Hardware Error]: TSC 0
> mce: [Hardware Error]: PROCESSOR 2:a20f10 TIME 1750853778 SOCKET 0 APIC 2 microcode a20102d
The issue is seemingly far more widespread than people realize. My memory is otherwise 100% stable because I've run a 24-hour MemTest86 loop at least a couple of times and it didn't find any errors. However, it's important to note that sometimes it actually detects a single error, but it's not reproducible.
Let's put more stuff up there! (Score:2)
And now they want to put AI computers in space. What could possibly go wrong?
No ECC? (Score:1)
Consumer grade memory just takes bit flips, but ECCs do exist. Do you mean to tell me they don't use them at Airbus? -dk
Re: Why was the older version better? (Score:2)
They didn't take it out per se, they just forgot to include it. Probably some make flag omitted or something simple.
Re: (Score:3)
They don't really know what caused the glitch.
The cosmic ray hypothesis is just a conjecture.
So, they're rolling back to the previous version until they can figure it out.
If they're doing memory scrubbing, they might want to bump up the frequency.
If they aren't using semiconductors made with depleted boron, they should be.