Tokyo Court Finds Cloudflare Liable For Manga Piracy in Long-Running Lawsuit (torrentfreak.com)
- Reference: 0180146883
- News link: https://yro.slashdot.org/story/25/11/19/2247224/tokyo-court-finds-cloudflare-liable-for-manga-piracy-in-long-running-lawsuit
- Source link: https://torrentfreak.com/tokyo-court-finds-cloudflare-liable-for-manga-piracy-in-long-running-lawsuit-liable-for-piracy-following-manga-publishers-lawsuit-251119/
> After a wait of more than three and a half years, the Tokyo District Court rendered its decision this morning. In a statement provided to TorrentFreak by the publishers, they declare "Victory Against Cloudflare" after the Court determined that Cloudflare is indeed liable for the pirate sites' activities. In a statement provided to TorrentFreak, the publishers explain that they alerted Cloudflare to the massive scale of the infringement, involving over 4,000 works and 300 million monthly visits, but their requests to stop distribution were ignored.
>
> "We requested that the company take measures such as stopping the distribution of pirated content from servers under its management. However, Cloudflare continued to provide services to the manga piracy sites even after receiving notices from the plaintiffs," the group says. The publishers add that Cloudflare continued to provide services even after receiving information disclosure orders from U.S. courts, leaving them with "no choice but to file this lawsuit."
>
> "The judgment recognized that Cloudflare's failure to take timely and appropriate action despite receiving infringement notices from the plaintiffs, and its negligent continuation of pirated content distribution, constituted aiding and abetting copyright infringement, and that Cloudflare bears liability for damages to the plaintiffs," they write. "The judgment, in that regard, attached importance to the fact that Cloudflare, without conducting any identity verification procedures, had enabled a massive manga piracy site to operate "under circumstances where strong anonymity was secured,' as a basis for recognizing the company's liability."
>
> The publishers believe that the judgment clarifies the conditions under which a company such as Cloudflare incurs liability for copyright infringement. Failure to carry out identity verification appears at the top of the publishers' list, followed by a lack of timely and appropriate action in response to infringement notices sent by rightsholders. "We believe this is an important decision given the current situation where piracy site operators often hide their identities and repeatedly conduct large-scale distribution using CDN services from overseas. We hope that this judgment will be a step toward ensuring proper use of CDN services. We will continue our efforts to protect the rights of works, creators, and related parties, while aiming for further expansion of legitimate content," the publishers conclude.
Cloudflare [2]plans to appeal the verdict.
[1] https://torrentfreak.com/tokyo-court-finds-cloudflare-liable-for-manga-piracy-in-long-running-lawsuit-liable-for-piracy-following-manga-publishers-lawsuit-251119/
[2] https://www.japantimes.co.jp/business/2025/11/19/companies/cloudflare-manga-piracy/
If cloudflare leaves japan (Score:2)
Will japan sue for the all the ddos they get hit with?
Re: (Score:1)
Will japan sue for the all the ddos they get hit with?
Cloudflare doesn't have a monopoly on protecting against DDOS attacks.
Large companies never do that (Score:2)
The risk of creating a viable competitor is too big so they will do pretty much anything a government wants in order to avoid being kicked out of the country.
It's not about the profit they can make in the country it's about making sure that there is never a viable competitor that could enter into any of your other markets.
Ultimately there really isn't a lot these companies do that's special. The most we survived because they're the ones who when the market was developing survived via survivorship bi
A reminder (Score:2)
When you play in someone else's playground, you play by their rules and their umpires.
The EU Ministry Of Truth approves of this (Score:1, Troll)
This will set a whole new precedent to block 'undesired' content in Europe.
can’t wait for them to exit! (Score:2)
this isn’t cloudflare’s job. they are just the middle man. okay, let’s see how a country reacts without them. i’m game.
I don't like it. (Score:2)
It incentivizes CF to leave Japan, which will hurt everyone but most of all Japan.
did they have an court order to stop distribution (Score:2)
did they have an court order to stop distribution how much verifying was done that X site was hosting copyright abuse and not fair use?
Re: (Score:3)
Clouldflare flaunts copyright law, and when you send a DMCA they just turn around and go "we are protected by the DMCA, pbbt."
c. Information Residing on Systems or Networks At Direction of Users
1.a
(i)does not have actual knowledge that the material or an activity using the material on the system or network is infringing;
(ii)in the absence of such actual knowledge, is not aware of facts or circumstances from which infringing activity is apparent; or
(iii)upon obtaining such knowledge or awareness, acts exped
Re: did they have an court order to stop distribut (Score:2)
That's not what flaunts means, you wanted flouts.