Daylight Saving Time: Still Happening. Still Unpopular (yahoo.com)
- Reference: 0179936336
- News link: https://yro.slashdot.org/story/25/11/02/0626222/daylight-saving-time-still-happening-still-unpopular
- Source link: https://www.yahoo.com/news/article/daylight-saving-time-2025-when-do-clocks-fall-back-an-hour-this-weekend-and-why-do-we-still-follow-this-controversial-ritual-200554820.html
But [1]does anyone like doing this, asks Yahoo News :
> A [2]recent AP-NORC poll found that about half of the American public, 47%, oppose the current daylight saving time system, compared to 40% who neither favor nor oppose the current practice, while 12% favor the current system, which involves most states switching their clocks twice a year.
>
> Of those polled, 56% would prefer to have daylight saving time year-round, meaning less light in the morning for a tradeoff of more light in the evening. While 42% of Americans said they would prefer to have standard time year-round, which means more light in the morning and less light in the evening. And 12% of Americans prefer switching between standard time and daylight saving time.
>
> Sleep doctors would prefer we switch to standard time permanently. "The U.S. should eliminate seasonal time changes in favor of a national, fixed, year-round time," the American Academy of Sleep Medicine said in a statement published in the Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine last year. "Current evidence best supports the adoption of year-round standard time, which aligns best with human circadian biology and provides distinct benefits for public health and safety."
[1] https://www.yahoo.com/news/article/daylight-saving-time-2025-when-do-clocks-fall-back-an-hour-this-weekend-and-why-do-we-still-follow-this-controversial-ritual-200554820.html
[2] https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/heres-americans-feel-changing-clocks-122325941.html
Govt knows best (Score:4, Funny)
If it were not good for the people, the govt would NEVER require it.
NEVER.
Re: Govt knows best (Score:2)
Sooo like genocide?
Permanently wrong time is silly (Score:2)
If you're going to have the same UTC+? time throughout the year, that should be chosen so that the sun is at its highest point at noon somewhere close to the centre of the zone using this time. If this means you're doing things at the wrong time, change the time at which you do these things, don't make time itself perpetually silly. The only sensible reason to have time where the sun sometimes peaks in the wrong place is if you want to change the sun-based time at which you do things between winter and summ
Re: (Score:1)
Yeah, if you ask people to wake up an hour earlier in the summer, they'll reply "no, I can't, I'm not a morning person". But when you set the clocks forward by an hour, they're all happy because they have "more daylight" in the evening which is great because they're not a morning person. Go figure.
Re: (Score:2)
Think of Spain.
Their dictator - General Franco - adopted the same time zone as Germany in order to express his love of Adolf Hitler, that was effectively permanent summer time. I don't know if Germany had DST during WW2 (I think they did) but they did not reintroduce DST until around 1980, Spain followed suit.
Bottom line, Spain is effectively on Summer Time in winter, and two hours ahead in summer. The Spanish have adapted in that they do everything an hour later than the other countries in their time zon
Americans vote gooder (Score:4, Funny)
We've seen what Americans will vote for.
They've proven they don't deserve a say in the matter...
Re: Americans vote gooder (Score:2)
You must represent the all knowing pygmie tribes
Congress needs to do away with DST, but... (Score:2)
Congress needs to do away with DST, but they can't do their job now !!
Inability to judge short vs long term effects (Score:3)
Twice a year people feel the slight inconvenience of a couple days to adjust their sleep schedule a whole one single hour. Which is something noticeable plus you may actually have to manually adjust some clocks, so that then feels important as something that disrupts the regular routine. Now; you cannot in the same way feel the same pain of being an hour out of sync with the ideal day/light rhythm, because it's a more subtle effect - but it is there ... and it is there for the better part of 180 days! Level of inconvenience multiplied by the number of times you are inconvenienced, and the latter scenario is much worse.
People increasingly seem unable to judge tangible short term gains vs longer term losses. You only have to turn to politics to see that, people electing leaders who dangle some short term prize in front of them, like "I will bring down prices of eggs" or whatever; people elect them because of those short term narrow scope promises, and next thing those politicians start tearing down their world over the long term across the board. And then those voters start complaining about what happened, when what happens was telegraphed years in advance. But those voters seem simply ... unable ... to ... think ... long ... term. But hey, maybe they got cheaper eggs for a month or two, so that is something.
Or take pain medication with opiates as an example. You are offered addictive pills to get rid of a modest amount of pain that normally you'd be able to grind your teeth a little bit and live through it. But you'd rather have no pain at all, so you take the pills, plus the ads say pain is something which has to be treated, talk to your big pharma sponsored doctor. And you repeat that choice to take the meds, again and again. Wind the clock forward one DST or two, and you are an addict. Turns out taking the meds was a net loss for you.
Where is the detail? (Score:1)
What I find more interesting than this so-called poll is the lack of transparency from AP-NORC. Where is the ANOVA? What polling methodology was used? Who and more importantly, where, was the sample audience? None of this seems to be available online. Also, why does the provided link point to an ad-laden Yahoo site vs AP-NORC directly? Why too is there scarce online detail on the Trump-quoted American Academy of Sleep Medicine?
A proper ANOVA would need to at least track the latitude of those polled.
Health First. GMT for all. (Score:2)
56% vs 42% in America? We should probably pay attention to the sleep doctors on this one instead of spoiled people who simply want their flavor of change to take effect, because no change.
No. The plants and other living animals waking to a rising sun in fact do not give a shit. When you can get any one of them to read a clock, I'll believe otherwise. Clocks are a human constraint against reality. Live in Zulu time, and you'll find you don't even need to acknowledge DST silliness. Ever.
GMT for all. An
Re: (Score:2)
Uhhh, I don't think people all agree on the year. Islam, Hebrew, Chinese, Persian and others... They all have different years. They just adhere to Gregorian for intrrnational relationships.
Also I find the use of the word "our" to be a bit ironic considering the Reformation. All y'all reformed and protestant denomination basically have just one thing you truly agree on which is dislike of Catholics ;).
Re: (Score:1)
GMT wouldn't make a difference. Americans are not going to get up at 7 am GMT when it's the middle of the night for them. So instead of saying "what time is it over there", we'd be asking "what time do they get up there, what time do business open there, 3 pm?". At least time zones make it clear what time of day it is, with business hours being pretty much the same everywhere. Also, having the date change in the middle of the afternoon is not exactly ideal either.
Funnily enough, your very point that plants
Re: (Score:2)
WHOOSH! He was reflecting the idiot nature of the argument that a one-hour time shift every six months has negative health effects.
If you want to feel such effects for real then try a job that has rotating shifts.
Re: (Score:2)
So because there are worse things to endure we should stop trying to better everything else that isn't the worst?
Kinda weird way to look at life.
Re: (Score:1)
asdasd das da da da dsadadadfaf afds asdf as f afd a f adf a dsfaf