Broadcom's Prohibitive VMware Prices Create a Learning 'Barrier,' IT Pro Says (arstechnica.com)
- Reference: 0179521384
- News link: https://it.slashdot.org/story/25/09/24/2022232/broadcoms-prohibitive-vmware-prices-create-a-learning-barrier-it-pro-says
- Source link: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2025/09/broadcoms-prohibitive-vmware-prices-create-a-learning-barrier-it-pro-says/
> When the COVID-19 pandemic forced kids to stay home, educators flocked to VMware, and thousands of school districts adopted virtualization. The technology became a solution for distance learning during the pandemic and after, when events such as bad weather and illness can prevent children from physically attending school. However, the VMware being sold to K-12 schools today differs from the VMware that existed before and during the pandemic. Now a Broadcom business, the platform features [1]higher prices and a business strategy that [2]favors big spenders . This has [3]created unique problems for educational IT departments juggling restrictive budgets and multiple technology vendors with children's needs.
>
> Ars Technica recently spoke with an IT director at a public school district in Indiana. The director requested anonymity for themself and the district out of concern about potential blowback. The director confirmed that the district has five schools and about 3,000 students. The district started using VMware's vSAN, a software-defined storage offering, and the vSphere virtualization platform in 2019. The Indiana school system bought the VMware offerings through a package that combined them with VxRail, which is hyperconverged infrastructure (HCI) hardware that Dell jointly engineered with VMware.
>
> However, like many of VMware customers, the Indiana school district was priced out of VMware after Broadcom's acquisition of the company. The IT director said the district received a quote that was "three to six" times higher than expected. This came as the school district is looking to manage changes in education-related taxes and funding over the next few years. As a result, the district's migration from VMware is taking IT resources from other projects, including ones aimed at improving curriculum. For instance, the Indiana district has been trying to bolster its technology curriculum, the IT director said. One way is through a summer employment program for upperclassmen that teaches how to use real-world IT products, like VMware and Cisco Meraki technologies. The district previously relied on VMware-based virtual machines (VMs) for creating "very easily and accessible" test environments for these students. But the school is no longer able to provide that opportunity, creating a learning "barrier," as the IT director put it.
The IT director told Ars that dealing with a migration could be "catastrophic in that that's too much work for one person," adding: "It could be a chokehold, essentially, to where they're going to be basically forced into switching platforms -- maybe before they were anticipating -- or paying exorbitant prices that have skyrocketed for absolutely no reason. Nothing on the software side has changed. It's the same software. There's no features being added. Nobody's benefiting from the higher prices on the education side."
[1] https://slashdot.org/story/25/05/22/1818256/vmware-price-hikes-between-800-and-1500-since-acquisition-by-broadcom-claim-euro-customers
[2] https://tech.slashdot.org/story/25/07/16/236216/vmware-reboots-its-partner-program-again-with-new-invite-only-program
[3] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2025/09/broadcoms-prohibitive-vmware-prices-create-a-learning-barrier-it-pro-says/
Real world IT (Score:2)
Is not name brands but concepts and theory. Name brands come and go. This is a perfect teaching experience. chances are the students may teach the school board something.
THEN STOP USING IT! (Score:4, Insightful)
This is a problem that solves itself. If VMware isn't in your price range then STOP USING IT. Problem solved.
> As a result, the district's migration from VMware is taking IT resources from other projects
THEN STOP USING IT!
> It could be a chokehold, essentially, to where they're going to be basically forced into switching platforms
Why would you wait to be forced when you can simply make the transition on your own terms right now? STOP USING IT!
The funny thing is that companies expect IT admins to be super flexible and learn new systems as needed but it seems these people who are teaching it are unwilling to adapt.
> Nobody's benefiting from the higher prices on the education side.
THEN STOP USING IT!
What the hell is wrong with this guy?! He knows the answer but he seems to be fighting tooth an nail to keep from recognizing that the school district should stop using VMware products!
Re: (Score:3)
>> As a result, the district's migration from VMware is taking IT resources from other projects
> THEN STOP USING IT!
Do you understand that "migration from VMWare" is synonymous with stopping using it?
Migrating away is a process that requires a lot of work, which means it is "taking IT resources from other projects."
Re: (Score:2)
He hasn't figured out that the company is pricing him out because they don't want him as a customer. If the schools are public shouldn't they use public software?
Re: (Score:2)
I said it above: VirtualBox. If it can provide the same service, it's completely free for educational use.
Re: (Score:2)
And please stop saying it because trying to compare VirualBox and vSphere just shows how little you know other than a simple user.
Re: (Score:2)
This is a common pattern on Slashdot. People saying, "Why doesn't everyone switch to
Re: (Score:2)
> "There are alternatives to vSphere, but VirtualBox definitely isn't one of them."
Indeed it is not. This isn't about running a desktop virtualization for a single user. It is about virtualization of services on servers. A much better comparison would be to XCP-ng/Xen Orchestra and Proxmox. They are powerful, open-source, optionally-commercially-supported, free to low-cost, feature-rich, and have a good track record. But they are lacking some of the very high-end services that some of VMWare's produc
KVM? Podman? (Score:2)
This seems like a problem all these school districts could come together and solve. Or just partner with a cloud provider. I'm embarrassed for them that this article wasn't titled, "thousands of schools districts ditch VMware for XYZ."
Vendor lock in (Score:3)
That's what this is called and they know it and use it. Have seen it in real work situation with a different vendor. 5 times the subscription price when we needed to move an application to a different server due to OS and infra upgrades. If your technicians are smart enough, you must move away from such "partners". Yes, will cost a bit more that year, but still cheaper longterm.
Broadcom STOP killing me (Score:1)
I'll be migrating companies to proxmox 2 years after im dead at this point......im doing 25 migrations at a time and still booked out a year... Broadcom slow down the destruction of VMware for a month let me catch up.....FRFR
Anyone who didn't see this coming (Score:3)
has been living under a rock. I've been retired 3 years and I was trying to alert my former employer that this was coming before my last day. Got no audience at all, they had bigger things on their minds. I wonder what they're doing now.
I found Proxmox to be a good replacement for vSphere, though maybe not as polished. But TONS of features nonetheless.
Sounds like a dumb IT manager (Score:2)
Who is both begging for more money, and desperately trying to cover his own ass. Anyone with half a brain could see this coming a mile off. I'd be inclined to sack the managerial team that dove head first into VMware, and continued to push it, in spite of the obvious.
Move away from a dead product (Score:2)
If you do not, all effects of that are on you.
The crackpipe of subscription licenses (Score:4, Insightful)
Who cares about profitability tomorrow? I need big numbers today.
Re: (Score:2)
If it works, VirtualBox is the answer. That should also help Broadcom's bottom line tomorrow.
Re: (Score:3)
The strategy of grabbing companies with big budgets by the balls has worked for Oracle for a long, long time. Ellison has been swapping back and forth with Musk as "world's richest man" lately.
Re: The crackpipe of subscription licenses (Score:2)
The difference here is that with a database ecosystem you can lock in your customers while with a virtualization environment your applications don't depend on which hypervisor you use.
Broadcom knows this and is very aggressive with the pricing to reap off profits quickly and leave an empty shell that they close as non-profitable.